[How About This Book] Before Retribution: Is This Also School Violence?
"Is This Also School Violence?" by Inseo Kim, Hanjun Kim, Jawon Moon, Sujin Lee, and Jaeun Lee
How Netflix's "True Education" Tapped Into Classroom Rage
Beyond Punishing Perpetrators: Why Distinguishing Harm, Responsibility, and Restoration Matters
In the classroom of Netflix's "True Education," state authority enters the scene. Its name is explicit: the National Office for the Protection of Teachers' Rights. Supervisors are dispatched to schools to restore the collapsed authority of teachers, and perpetrators, bystanders, and reckless adults in the classroom become targets of retribution one after another. It is a narrative that instantly sweeps away the frustrations of reality. That is why it feels exhilarating, and that is why it is dangerous. On the surface, the drama seems to ask, "Who will set this classroom right?" But there is a more painful question: Why is it that, when faced with classroom problems, we imagine punishment before education?
"Is This Also School Violence?" begins from the opposite side of that fantasy. Here, there are neither supervisors nor villains who are conveniently dealt with in a single blow. Instead, there are questions that are often heard in real classrooms. If a child comes home having been hit, does that count as school violence? If there is a fight, who is the perpetrator? If no one plays with a child, is that bullying? Isn't it too early to call it blackmail? How should we view 'touching' between children? Can we trust that everything our child says is true?
These questions, listed in the first part of the book, get right to the heart of the reality of school violence. School violence rarely begins as clearly as a legal term. It starts vaguely—in pranks, quarrels, hurt feelings, exclusion, jokes, unwanted physical contact, or a single line in a group chat room.
That is why this book first establishes standards, not anger. The authors present three core criteria for judging school violence: intent, repetition, and an imbalance of power. Was it a joke meant to be enjoyed together, or was there intent to embarrass or harm? Was it a one-time mistake, or did it continue even after refusal? Was the relationship equal, or did invisible differences—such as physique, popularity, or social status—silence one side? These are the questions that must be asked.
While "True Education" asks, "Who should be punished?" this book asks an even more fundamental question: "What should we recognize as violence?" Retribution is swift, but judgment is slow. Sometimes, what a classroom needs is that slowness.
The book becomes clearer when it introduces real-life cases. Part Three categorizes seven types of violence: verbal violence, ostracism, extortion, coercion, physical violence, sexual violence, and cyberbullying. This is not a simple classification; it is a list that shows the many faces of school violence today. The phrase, "It can be violence even if there is no hitting," is at the core of this book.
School violence can no longer be explained by a single punch. Nicknames, teasing, exclusion from group chats, persistent demands after someone says no, dismissive physical contact because "they're just kids," and pressure surrounding money or belongings—all of these are included in the assessment. The book also points out that official casebooks from education offices often cover only a narrow and fragmented range due to a focus on student rights, which limits on-site judgment. The authors state that they have adapted actual cases from schools to increase relatability while protecting the identities of those involved.
The book takes a more nuanced approach in its treatment of perpetrators and victims. While it does not minimize the pain of victims, it also does not condemn perpetrators as irredeemable villains. The fourth part of the book is explicit: "An apology does not mean it's over," "More important than 'I'm sorry' is 'never again,'" and "It's okay to tell someone." An apology is not the end of an incident, but the beginning of responsibility.
What victims need is not to be told to quietly endure, but the sense of safety that comes from knowing it is okay to speak up. What perpetrators need is not a memory of being scolded, but learning the responsibility of never repeating their actions. The concept of restoring relationships only has meaning in this context. Reconciliation without responsibility merely demands more silence from the victim.
The backgrounds of the authors also say much about this book. It was co-authored by a current elementary school teacher, an educational psychology researcher, and a school violence specialist lawyer who was formerly a teacher, with a professor of educational psychology serving as advisor. The book covers the concept of school violence, real-life cases, the behavioral causes of victims and perpetrators, child psychology, and legal response procedures all in one volume. It repeatedly emphasizes that, rather than shifting responsibility when incidents arise, teachers and parents must cooperate to help children return to their daily lives.
The first thing to break down in the response to school violence is this cooperation. In trying to protect their own child, parents may turn other children into enemies; teachers, while following procedure, may lose the trust of both sides. Children are hurt anew within the language of these disputes. This is why the book includes a separate section titled "A United Front Against School Violence: Strategies for Teachers and Parents."
In the world of "True Education," solutions come quickly. The villain is exposed, authority acts without delay, and viewers feel that justice has finally arrived. But real classrooms do not close so easily. We must keep asking whether something is violence or just a joke, whether it is harm or just a quarrel, whether it is an apology or avoidance, whether it is punishment or restoration. The resonance of "Is This Also School Violence?" lies precisely there.
What a broken classroom needs is not a stronger fist, but more accurate standards. Soda may clear your throat, but it doesn't linger. What allows a classroom to breathe again is not the speed of retribution, but the persistence of judgment and responsibility.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Written by Inseo Kim, Hanjun Kim, Jawon Moon, Sujin Lee, and Jaeun Lee | Reviewed by Jeonggyu Lee | Page Media Bridge | 320 pages
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.