Accusations of Unfair Business Deals Worth KRW 24 Billion

Lower Courts: "No Intentional Wrongdoing," Not Guilty

Supreme Court: "Original Ruling Justified," Final Acquittal

Mirae Asset affiliates that were indicted on charges of unfairly channeling business to a golf course operated by a company in which the group owner's family holds a majority stake have been finally acquitted by the Supreme Court.

Yonhap News

Yonhap News

View original image

On the 25th, the Second Division of the Supreme Court (Presiding Justice Eom Sang-pil) upheld the original ruling of not guilty in the appeal trial of Mirae Asset Global Investments and Mirae Asset Life Insurance, which had been prosecuted for violating the Monopoly Regulation and Fair Trade Act.


The two companies were brought to trial on charges that, from January 2015 to December 2016, they colluded with executives and employees of group affiliates and conducted transactions amounting to approximately KRW 24,044,360,000 with Blue Mountain Country Club (now Sagewood) in Hongcheon County, Gangwon Province, operated by Mirae Asset Consulting, a company in which Park Hyun-joo, Chairman of Mirae Asset Group, and other specially related parties hold a 91.86% stake.


The prosecution argued that the companies provided unfair profits to specially related parties by holding entertainment, training, and events at the golf course without rational consideration or comparison with other businesses.


Initially, the prosecution brought summary indictments against the companies, and in April 2022 the court issued summary orders of a KRW 30 million fine each. However, both companies contested this and requested a formal trial. Both the first and second instance courts found the companies not guilty during the formal trial proceedings.


The first and second instance courts determined that the main reason Mirae Asset Consulting was entrusted with operating the golf course was because direct operation by the fund could have violated the Capital Markets Act and the Act on the Structural Improvement of the Financial Industry. They also found that due to the entrusted operation, Mirae Asset Consulting incurred operating losses of approximately KRW 930 million in 2015, and it was difficult to view that there was intent to provide unfair benefits to those parties.



The Supreme Court agreed with the original not-guilty verdict. The court concluded, "There is no violation of the laws of logic or experience, nor was there any misunderstanding of the legal principles regarding the offense of violating the Fair Trade Act, in the lower court’s decision."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing