First Subcommittee Meeting of the Korea Dairy Committee Held on June 30

Raw Milk Purchase Volumes for the Next Two Years to Be Decided

Differences in Negotiation Standards from the Outset... Talks Likely to Be Prolonged

As consumption of white milk continues to decline, dairy farmers—the producers—and dairy companies—the demand side—are beginning discussions on reducing the raw milk supply. To protect the domestic dairy industry, both parties have set certain procurement volumes of raw milk, but as changes in consumption make volume reductions inevitable, this year's negotiations are expected to be challenging.


According to the dairy industry on June 30, the Korea Dairy Committee will hold the first meeting of the Subcommittee on Raw Milk Base Price Adjustment today. Under the differential pricing system by use, introduced in 2023, the volumes allocated for each use are adjusted every two years, and the Korea Dairy Committee facilitates negotiations among stakeholders. Attendees will include three representatives each from dairy farmers, who produce raw milk, and dairy companies, who demand it. Dairy companies such as Maeil Dairies, Namyang Dairy Products, and Binggrae will participate.


[Why&Next] Expensive Surplus White Milk... Fierce Tug-of-War Over 'Raw Milk Quotas' View original image

What Is the Differential Pricing System... Adjusted Every Two Years

The differential pricing system by use sets different raw milk prices depending on how the milk is used. Before its introduction in 2023, dairy companies purchased raw milk from farmers at a uniform price, regardless of its intended use. However, while demand for drinking milk (fluid milk) has declined, demand for processed dairy products such as cheese, butter, and ice cream has increased.


In fact, white milk demand has been steadily decreasing each year since 2021. According to the Korea Dairy Committee, last year, per capita annual consumption of white milk was recorded at 22.9 kg. This represents a 9.5% decrease from the previous year and an 18% decrease compared to 2016 (27 kg), ten years ago. This is the lowest level since the late 1980s, when consumption of white milk began to surge. The drop in consumption is attributed to factors such as low birth rates, an increase in single-person households, and the expansion of imported and sterilized milk, which have impacted domestic white milk consumption.


[Why&Next] Expensive Surplus White Milk... Fierce Tug-of-War Over 'Raw Milk Quotas' View original image

The way raw milk is consumed has also changed. According to the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs and the Korea Dairy Committee, the volume of raw milk for drinking purposes decreased by 8.3% from 1,753,481 tons in 2021 to 1,607,678 tons last year. In contrast, raw milk for processed use increased by 22.2% during the same period, reaching 343,305 tons last year. In terms of the proportion of total raw milk production, raw milk for drinking purposes fell from 86.2% in 2021 to 82.4% last year, a drop of 3.8 percentage points.


The differential pricing system was established to match such consumption patterns by setting up a dual pricing structure. By pricing processed milk lower than drinking milk, the system prevents dairy companies from replacing domestically produced milk used in processed products with cheaper imports, while still enabling dairy companies to achieve some cost efficiency and allowing dairy farmers to survive.

"Buy 33,000 More Tons of White Milk" vs. "Not Purchasing the Entire Quota"

The volumes and prices for each use of raw milk are adjusted every two years and determined through negotiations among stakeholders, led by the Korea Dairy Committee. The newly adjusted volumes will take effect from January next year. When the system was introduced, the quota was set at 1.95 million tons for drinking milk and 100,000 tons for processed milk. In 2024, negotiations for 2025–2026 set the quotas at 1,941,000 tons for drinking milk and 109,000 tons for processed milk.


Since the outcome of these negotiations directly affects the interests of both sides, both are firmly defending their positions. The dairy companies emphasize that, since white milk consumption has sharply decreased and they are already absorbing excess supply, the quota for drinking milk should be reduced. The industry notes that, given last year's actual consumption of 1,607,678 tons, they are purchasing over 330,000 tons more than the market requires.


[Why&Next] Expensive Surplus White Milk... Fierce Tug-of-War Over 'Raw Milk Quotas' View original image

The unit purchase price of raw milk for companies such as Namyang Dairy Products, Maeil Dairies, and Binggrae has steadily increased over the past three years, with last year's unit price rising by 4.5% to 6.8% compared to 2023.


An industry insider criticized, "Does it make sense to buy expensive milk and have to sell the surplus at a discount?" The source added, "Since not all white milk can be sold, it is processed into products like skim milk powder, but because we have to purchase expensive domestic drinking milk to make these products, production costs rise and profitability inevitably declines." For skim milk powder, the production cost of domestic milk is about three times higher than that of imports, the insider pointed out.


Last year, Namyang Dairy Products recorded an operating profit margin of 0.57%. While this is an improvement over the previous year's negative margin, it remains extremely low. The company's cost of goods sold ratio is close to 80%, which is high even among dairy companies. For Maeil Dairies and Binggrae, last year's operating profit margins fell by 0.62 percentage points and 3.04 percentage points, respectively, compared to 2024. Over the past three years, Maeil Dairies’ cost of goods sold ratio has risen by 1.11 percentage points, and Binggrae’s by 2.52 percentage points.


[Why&Next] Expensive Surplus White Milk... Fierce Tug-of-War Over 'Raw Milk Quotas' View original image

Dairy farmers counter that, since the implementation of the differential pricing system, the actual volume purchased by dairy companies from farmers is lower than the quota. They also argue that the dairy industry, citing domestic raw milk prices, has increasingly used cheaper imported dairy products, neglecting domestic raw milk. While some point out that the high price of domestic raw milk drives up consumer milk prices, farmers criticize the dairy companies’ excessive distribution margins as the real cause.


Farmers further explain that, due to production cost issues and volume reductions, closures of dairy farms have surged. A representative of the Korea Dairy & Beef Farmers Association stated, "Only a portion of the production cost is being covered by the raw milk price. Dairy companies focused on government support and duty-free benefits while neglecting domestic raw milk and rushing to replace it with cheaper imports—this is the real issue."


However, dairy farm production costs, on an annual basis, turned downward last year for the first time in a decade since 2016. According to Statistics Korea, production costs, which had steadily risen since 2016, soared by 14% after fertilizer prices jumped following the Russia-Ukraine war in February 2022. After rising to 1,018 won in 2024, production costs saw a slight decline last year. Due to the surge in production costs, dairy farmers’ income per cow dropped sharply from 3,651,000 won in 2021 to 2,801,000 won in 2022, but has increased for three consecutive years since then. Last year, it was 3,541,000 won, up 2.1% from the previous year.


[Why&Next] Expensive Surplus White Milk... Fierce Tug-of-War Over 'Raw Milk Quotas' View original image

As a result of the drop in production costs, one of the key negotiation items—raw milk price—was frozen last month. Raw milk price negotiations are held only when production costs rise or fall by more than 4% year-on-year, but last year, production costs fell by just 0.4% from the prior year, failing to meet the threshold. The price of raw milk for drinking is 1,084 won per liter, and for processed milk, 882 won per liter. Raw milk prices have now been frozen for three consecutive years. With prices on hold, the focus of this year’s negotiations has shifted to volume adjustments.

Sharp Division from the Start... Negotiations Likely to Remain Deadlocked for Now

Negotiations are likely to face difficulties from the outset, as both sides differ even on the criteria for calculating how much supply should be cut.


Dairy companies argue that the official quota of 1,941,000 tons for drinking milk should be used. Dairy farmers, however, insist that the actual amount purchased—which is less than the quota—should be the basis. Citing government data referenced by the Korea Dairy & Beef Farmers Association, the actual amount purchased by dairy companies was about 1.8 million tons, which is 81.2% of the 2.2 million ton reference point.


Because negotiations are being held to reduce some of the excess supply based on actual demand, the selection of the reference point is likely to be a critical factor for both sides as they seek to gain an advantage. Since the price of processed milk is about 81% of that for drinking milk, dairy farmers want to minimize the expansion of the processed milk quota, while dairy companies seek to maximize it.


Given these circumstances, it seems unlikely that negotiations will conclude in a short period. When the differential pricing system was introduced in 2023, the first round of negotiations in 2024 also took a long time to conclude—the talks began in early June and did not end until late July. At that time, the issue was the price rather than the volume, but the process still took longer than expected.



[Why&Next] Expensive Surplus White Milk... Fierce Tug-of-War Over 'Raw Milk Quotas' View original image

An industry insider commented, "Because both sides have to discuss uncomfortable topics, even the first meeting was scheduled late, and there is no sign that the gap between their positions is narrowing." The insider added, "In principle, the negotiation period is one month, but at this point, it is unclear whether talks will conclude in August, September, or later."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing