"Minister of Foreign Affairs' Approval Required for Visiting Certain Countries"

Proceedings Halted Due to Article 17(1) of the Passport Act

It has been confirmed that there is a case in which a court has not reached a conclusion for more than three years after receiving an application for a request for a constitutional review. Even considering that the court's regulation, which stipulates that cases should be handled "within 180 days of receipt," is merely an advisory provision without binding force, the legal community points out that such long delays are highly unusual.


Judge A, who was serving as a single criminal judge at the Goyang Branch of the Uijeongbu District Court, received an application for a constitutional review from the defendant in a case involving a violation of the Passport Act in June 2023.

Photo for article illustration. Pixabay.

Photo for article illustration. Pixabay.

View original image

The applicant, photographer Jang Jinyoung, received a summary order imposing a fine of 5 million won on charges of entering Ukraine without permission for a photography assignment in March 2022, right after the outbreak of the Russia-Ukraine war. He subsequently requested a formal trial and applied to have the court refer the case to the Constitutional Court for a constitutional review. The argument was that Article 17, Paragraph 1, proviso of the Passport Act, which requires the approval of the Minister of Foreign Affairs to visit or stay in certain countries, excessively restricts freedom of expression and is therefore unconstitutional.


After conducting the seventh hearing in February 2024, Judge A halted further proceedings to review the application for constitutional review. In cases where the question of constitutionality of the statutory basis for the trial is significant enough, it is common to stop the substantive hearing and then decide whether to accept the application. If the constitutionality claim is unlikely to affect the main judgment, it is often dismissed concurrently at the time of sentencing. Judge A did not reach a conclusion on the application and was transferred to another court in February 2026.


In November 2023, five months after receiving the application, the Goyang Branch erroneously entered in the "My Cases" electronic system that the application had been granted as the final result. The Goyang Branch later corrected the information, attributing the mistake to an administrative error. If the written decision does not reach the parties, the mere indication in the electronic system does not grant legal effect to the ruling.


The court rule titled "Regulation on Handling Requests for Constitutional Review of Statutes" stipulates that "the court that receives the application shall decide within 180 days from the date of receipt, unless there are special circumstances" (Article 7). Judge A conveyed through the court that it was difficult to answer questions about whether there were any circumstances making a decision difficult or what was handed over to the successor judge. The successor judge has resumed the trial and stated that a decision will be made by the end of June on whether to grant the application.


There is criticism that it is highly unusual for a constitutional review application to take three years. In single-judge criminal cases, the main case itself is usually concluded within six months. As of 2024, the average duration for disposition of single-judge first-instance criminal cases was 115.2 days for cases involving detention and 189.2 days for cases without detention. The court does not manage statistics specifically on the status of constitutional review applications. However, the court side has stated, "We understand that decisions are made within 180 days in more cases than not."


Kim Kwangjae, attorney at Shin & Kim LLC (Judicial Research and Training Institute Class 34), who has represented many constitutional litigation cases, stated, "If the court had promptly dismissed the application, there would have been time to file a direct constitutional complaint and obtain the Constitutional Court's judgment." He added, "Regardless of the constitutionality of the underlying legal provision, such trial delays severely undermine the procedural right to a speedy trial, which is guaranteed by the Constitution."


Recently, the court has moved to determine whether delays in constitutional review proceedings at the Constitutional Court infringe upon the right to a speedy trial. The 50th Criminal Division of the Seoul Central District Court (presiding judge Jeon Boseong, Senior Chief Judge) announced on June 17 that, because the Constitutional Court has not reached a conclusion for nearly four years regarding a constitutional complaint filed by a defendant, it will examine whether this is unconstitutional or illegal. The court indicated that the Constitutional Court's delay could be viewed as an omission that infringes on the right to a speedy trial.



Park Seongdong, Legal Times Reporter


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing