US Big Tech Offers Massive Compensation to Employees
Implements Restructuring and Pay Cuts in Times of Crisis
Revamping Performance Evaluation Systems
Establishing Individual Recruitment over Mass Hiring

[Insight & Opinion] Samsung's Profit Distribution Dispute: An Opportunity to Innovate HR Systems View original image

Watching the process of distributing performance bonuses at Samsung Electronics, which drew intense attention in our market last month, I found it difficult to comprehend and could not help but feel dismay. In particular, the labor union's actions, which bordered on extortion by leveraging a strike, were especially troubling.


It is important to be wary of such extreme developments and to closely examine whose contributions truly led to these extraordinary achievements. Even if performance bonuses are awarded, they should rightfully go to the individuals and groups who made substantive contributions. To ensure this, a serious analysis of the process that led to these outcomes is essential. Without such analysis, allowing those who happen to belong to the organization at present to receive astronomical bonuses is, in many ways, unfair.


This year, Samsung Electronics achieved unprecedented results in its semiconductor business division. However, we must not overlook the 'contributions' made by the smartphone and home appliance divisions, which have generated profits while the semiconductor business had been operating at a loss for several years. The current success in semiconductors was possible only because the company could continue investing with money earned from other business sectors.


It is hard to accept that, within the same company, a particular business division would receive performance bonuses one hundred times larger than another. Such an occurrence is unheard of even among the world's leading global companies, and it is difficult to find similar cases in history. It was also unusual to see the group chairman apologizing to the entire nation over the internal conflict regarding performance bonuses. Ultimately, the management's decision to partially accept the union's demands and agree to large-scale bonus payments also appears unreasonable. I believe this will remain a significant blemish, not only for the company but also for our entire industry.


The distribution of profits should always be conducted rationally according to the company's management strategy. Rather than focusing on satisfying workers in the short term, it is more beneficial to allocate resources for future investments and reserves to prepare for crises. Naturally, an appropriate level of dividends for shareholders should also take priority.


Considering these points, I hope this dispute over performance bonuses can serve as an opportunity to innovate the company's HR system. In particular, a system should be established to ensure that teams and individuals who contribute to performance receive fair rewards. There needs to be a system for setting goals and evaluations so that the achievements of the company, teams, and individuals are interconnected. Rather than relying on conflict, compensation should be determined according to the system, so that each team and individual is rewarded based on their respective contributions.


After concluding the Samsung Electronics wage negotiations held on the 20th of last month at the Gyeonggi Employment and Labor Office in Jangan District, Suwon City, Gyeonggi Province, Yeomyeong Gu, Head of the People Team at Samsung Electronics Device Solutions (semiconductor business division), and Seungho Choi, Chairman of the Samsung Electronics Branch of the Samsung Group Super-Enterprise Labor Union, signed the tentative agreement and shook hands. [Joint coverage] Photo by Yonhap News Agency

After concluding the Samsung Electronics wage negotiations held on the 20th of last month at the Gyeonggi Employment and Labor Office in Jangan District, Suwon City, Gyeonggi Province, Yeomyeong Gu, Head of the People Team at Samsung Electronics Device Solutions (semiconductor business division), and Seungho Choi, Chairman of the Samsung Electronics Branch of the Samsung Group Super-Enterprise Labor Union, signed the tentative agreement and shook hands. [Joint coverage] Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

It is also urgent to establish an individualized hiring system instead of mass recruitment. This means that negotiations are conducted on an individual basis at the time of hiring, and an individual employment contract specifying all conditions, including salary, is concluded accordingly. Since not every position within the company requires the same competencies, such a system is necessary. It is also important to recognize that the market value for each competency varies. For a more advanced corporate culture, an individualized employment contract system is essential.


There are reports from foreign media that, with the listing of SpaceX, thousands of current and former employees will become millionaires through stock compensation. However, compensation will inevitably vary individually, depending on the timing of employment, duration of service, job position, and stock option prices. It is only right that individuals are evaluated and rewarded based on their entry conditions, work content, and performance. Only then will everyone have the motivation to strive for greater achievements. Lifting the cap on performance bonuses should be accompanied by the condition that employees share the burden when the company faces difficulties. I hope all members of the company are aware of this. Executives at SpaceX and NVIDIA have made similar remarks. Many major U.S. tech companies are already granting massive rewards to employees, but at the same time, they strongly demand acceptance of restructuring, wage cuts, and the dismissal of underperformers during crises. Only by accepting these conditions can one be eligible for significant rewards. Providing rewards in the form of stock options, encouraging employees to work together for the company's long-term growth, is also considered an effective approach.


As society becomes more advanced, the methods of reward become more diverse, and more factors can be considered. I hope that, through this opportunity, Samsung Electronics and other companies will be able to lay the foundation for establishing an advanced corporate culture by innovating their HR systems.



Kim Hongjin, CEO of Work Innovation Lab


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing