First Trial Found Hong Liable, Ordered 66 Billion Won in Damages

In the appellate trial for a damages claim filed by private equity fund (PEF) manager Hahn & Company (Hahn & Co.) against Won Sik Hong, former chairman of Namyang Dairy Products, the causal relationship between 'owner risk' and the decline in corporate value has emerged as a key issue.

Hwang Won-shik, former chairman of Namyang Dairy Products. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

Hwang Won-shik, former chairman of Namyang Dairy Products. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

On the morning of June 24, the Seoul High Court's Civil Division 12-2 held the first hearing of the appellate trial for the damages lawsuit brought by Hahn & Co. against Hong and others. The court stated that it was necessary to discuss the logic of 'decline in corporate value due to owner risk,' as accepted in the first trial. The court remarked, "There is room to consider whether the Bulgaris incident constitutes owner risk or corporate risk. The first trial ruled that the company's value declined due to owner risk without providing supporting arguments."


The two parties clashed over the method for calculating corporate value. The plaintiff, Hahn & Co., argued that damages should be calculated based on the discounted cash flow (DCF) method. Hahn & Co. claimed, "During the period of delay in the acquisition, market share fell from 14% to the 12% range, which adversely affected operating profit and other indicators."


On the other hand, the defendant, former chairman Hong, argued that value should be assessed based on the market's evaluation, specifically the 'stock price,' and contended that there were issues with Hahn & Co.'s calculation method. Hong's side stated, "The decline in market share was due to the overall contraction of the infant formula market, the core product segment," and further argued, "Hahn & Co. overestimated the damages by assuming the decline in market share would persist."


To review the parties' claims, the court requested submission of objective data regarding the business performance and asset value fluctuations of Namyang Dairy Products and the four major domestic milk companies from the time of the incident to the present. The court emphasized, "Official financial statements are more important than privately commissioned accounting reports."


Additionally, considering concerns over the leakage of trade secrets, the court decided that internal consulting reports held by Hahn & Co. would be reviewed through an 'in camera' procedure. The 'in camera' procedure refers to a confidential review process in which the court examines documents privately.


This lawsuit was filed by Hahn & Co. over damages incurred when former chairman Hong refused to fulfill the Stock Purchase Agreement (SPA) and failed to transfer management control. Previously, the first trial court found Hong liable and ordered him to pay 66 billion won in damages to Hahn & Co.



The next hearing in the appellate trial is scheduled for September 2 at 5:30 PM.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing