Strengthened Rights for Jeonse Fraud Victims Lead to Conflict Between LH and Tenants in Multi-Family Housing Auctions
When Both LH and Victims Exercise Right of First Refusal
Victims’ Rights Take Priority After Legal Amendment
Concerns Over Loss of Recovery Opportunity for Lower-Priority Tenants
Confusion is arising on the front lines due to authority issues between the victims of jeonse fraud and public housing operators, who are stepping in as relief pitchers in the process of resolving the damage. The typical method is for public housing operators to purchase the homes first and provide compensation. However, a recently established clause now gives priority to the victim's right if both parties simultaneously express their intent to exercise the right of first refusal. Previously, organizations like Korea Land & Housing Corporation (LH) would acquire homes on behalf of the victims, but now, with individual victims exercising their right of first refusal, clashes over authority have emerged. Since last month's legal amendment, a blind spot has been created, prompting calls for supplementary measures to resolve these conflicts.
According to industry sources on June 24, LH recently filed a petition with the Suwon District Court to prohibit the auction of a multi-family house in Hwaseong, Gyeonggi Province, which was awarded at 811 million won. The intention is to have LH's right of first refusal recognized over that of tenant A. In this property, five tenants have not received their jeonse deposits totaling 720 million won. Last year, after three subordinate tenants, including A, transferred their right of first refusal to LH, A unexpectedly exercised this right on the auction date and won the bid through what is being called a 'self-bid'.
Other subordinate tenants, who had planned to recover their losses from the auction surplus if LH purchased the home, now face the risk of losing a significant portion of their deposits. This is because, after approximately 750 million won is paid to senior creditors from financial institutions and to senior tenants as auction proceeds, there will effectively be nothing left for subordinate tenants.
Although a new minimum guarantee system has been introduced where the government supports recovery of up to one-third of the lost deposits, the amount is significantly less compared to what could have been recovered from the auction surplus paid by LH. Tenant B lamented, "I am at risk of losing my hard-earned deposit of 120 million won," adding, "Some tenants have ended up bankrupt, and those who took out jeonse loans continue to see interest payments withdrawn by financial institutions."
The reason the right to purchase was transferred to A is that the revision of the Jeonse Fraud Victim Act last month strengthened victims' right of first refusal. Under the revised law, if both the victim and the public housing operator submit a right of first refusal, and the victim applies for approval of their purchase bid by the auction closing date, the court is required to grant it. A Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport (MOLIT) official explained, "There had never been a case where both a victim and LH exercised the right of first refusal at the same time in the auction process for a multi-family jeonse fraud property," but added, "If this incident had occurred before the amendment, the decision would have been left to the court's discretion."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
The possibility of exercising dual rights is also being highlighted as a problem. Article 25 of the previous Jeonse Fraud Victim Support Act stated that when a victim requested to purchase, it would be deemed that the right of first refusal was transferred to the public housing operator. However, the amended law deleted the clause deeming it a transfer, leaving only the provision that a purchase request can be made. In other words, even if a victim requests LH to purchase the property, it is interpreted that the victim still retains the right of first refusal.
The Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport and LH see this issue as stemming from the amendment of the law, which was based on buildings that could be separately registered, such as multi-unit dwellings. Although the intention was to prioritize victims' choices, in the case of multi-family homes with a single registration and multiple affected tenants, the potential for conflicting claims to the right of first refusal among victims was not considered. An LH official stated, "When the rights of a majority of tenants who want LH to exercise the right of first refusal and a minority who wish to exercise it themselves collide, institutional improvements are needed to determine whose opinion should take precedence."
The Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport has also submitted an opinion to the court administration, emphasizing that multiple victims should not lose their opportunity for recovery due to conflicting rights. A ministry official explained, "Although the revised provisions were intended to prioritize victims' choices, the process of prioritizing an individual's rights could result in the loss of opportunities for other victims," adding, "We conveyed our view to the court that careful consideration is needed when such authority conflicts arise."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.