"True Education" Becomes Reality... Juvenile Offenders Steal 4 Million Won in Pokémon Cards, Respond with Just "E"
"Calls for Harsher Punishment" vs. "Erosion of Reform Principles": The Juvenile Offender Debate
Protective Measures Possible, But Restitution Remains a Distant Goal
Teenagers Account for 52% of Unmanned Store Theft Cases
Amid renewed debate over the juvenile offender system sparked by the Netflix series "True Education," controversy is once again mounting after it was reported that two middle school students in Gwangyang, South Jeolla Province, stole goods worth several million won, including Pokémon cards, from an unmanned store and fled the scene.
Two middle school students classified as minors exempt from prosecution stole Pokémon cards worth approximately 4 million won from an unmanned store and fled. JTBC 'Case Officer'
View original imageOn the 24th, JTBC's "Incident Report" covered the unmanned store incident that occurred in Gwangyang, South Jeolla Province. According to the report, the Gwangyang Police Station is currently investigating two teenage middle school students on suspicion of theft. On May 30, the suspects allegedly entered an unmanned store in Gwangyang with their faces covered and swept boxes of Pokémon cards and other items into plastic bags. The stolen goods were reported to be worth approximately 4 million won.
The store's closed-circuit television (CCTV) footage clearly captured the students covering their faces with clothing and removing card boxes from the shelves. It is reported that they opened all the stolen Pokémon cards in a public restroom at a nearby apartment complex, discarded the packaging, and left the scene. Some of the stolen items were later sold through a secondhand trading platform. The store owner personally contacted the seller and tracked down the suspects. Although the students sent another student to the meeting place in an attempt to avoid revealing their identities, they were eventually apprehended by the police.
The victim principal sent a text message to another student involved in theft, saying, "This is something to resolve with your parents, but even if the parents cannot resolve it, you will pay the price. I will pursue criminal and civil lawsuits to the end." The student replied briefly with "e." JTBC Incident Report
View original imagePolice investigation confirmed that both students are under the age of 14 and thus classified as minors exempt from prosecution. It was also revealed that one of them had already been sent to a juvenile detention center for a separate theft case. The victim store owner sent a text message to another student involved in theft, stating, "This is something to resolve with your parents, but even if the parents cannot resolve it, you will pay the price. I will pursue criminal and civil lawsuits to the end." The student replied briefly with "e." The parents of the student could not be reached. Speaking through a broadcast, the victim store owner appealed, "The total damages exceed 10 million won, but not only have the parents failed to reach a settlement, they have not even apologized. The hardest part of crimes committed by minors exempt from prosecution is that victims are left to bear the burden alone."
Frequent Thefts by Juvenile Offenders Targeting Unmanned Stores
This is not the first time that unmanned stores have been targeted by juvenile offenders. In March, it was reported that two brothers stole goods from an unmanned ice cream store in Paju, Gyeonggi Province, on more than 20 occasions over 13 months. The cumulative losses at the time amounted to about 970,000 won, and some of those involved were classified as minors exempt from prosecution and were released after receiving probation.
Unmanned stores have the advantage of reducing labor costs, but there are concerns that their reliance on closed-circuit television (CCTV) and kiosks makes them vulnerable to theft. The Asia Business Daily database
View original imageIn May, an 18-year-old was sentenced to prison for instructing middle school students—some of whom were minors exempt from prosecution—to steal a total of 2,495,000 won from several unmanned stores in Incheon, telling them, "You won't be criminally punished." In 2024, there were also cases where most of a group of teenagers who stole cash from unmanned stores across Seoul and Incheon were found to be minors exempt from prosecution.
Unmanned stores have the advantage of reducing labor costs, but concerns have been raised that their reliance on closed-circuit television (CCTV) and kiosks makes them vulnerable to theft. According to a big data analysis by security company S-1 of its customers from 2019 to June 2023, teenagers accounted for 52% of unmanned store thefts, the highest proportion. The most common time for these crimes was between midnight and 6 a.m., accounting for 61% of cases.
Even if criminal punishment is difficult to impose, the process for recovering damages is not completely blocked. Civil law stipulates that if a person lacking capacity causes damage to another, the legal guardian may be held liable for compensation. Court precedents have also recognized the liability of guardians, such as parents, if their supervisory obligations towards minors are found to have been neglected. However, critics point out that pursuing actual claims for damages requires time and money, ultimately placing the burden on small business owners who are victims.
81% Support Lowering the Age for Juvenile Offenders, but Debate Over Effectiveness and Human Rights Continues
The current Criminal Act of the Republic of Korea stipulates, "A person under the age of 14 shall not be punished." However, the Juvenile Act provides that boys and girls aged 10 or older but under 14 who violate criminal laws are to be tried as juvenile protection cases in juvenile court. In other words, while minors exempt from prosecution are not subject to criminal punishment, they may be subject to protective measures such as placement in custody, mandatory education, probation, or being sent to a juvenile detention center.
The juvenile offender system was established based on the premise that the responsibility and potential for rehabilitation of minors should be assessed differently from adults. The Juvenile Act aims to adjust the environment of antisocial juveniles and correct their behavior to support healthy development. The Asia Business Daily
View original imageThe juvenile offender system was established based on the premise that the responsibility and potential for rehabilitation of minors should be assessed differently from adults. The Juvenile Act aims to adjust the environment of antisocial juveniles and correct their behavior to support healthy development. It is described not simply as a "system to avoid punishment," but as a protective and corrective measure intended to reduce the stigma and prevent recidivism.
However, as cases like the unmanned store thefts continue to occur, with victims directly bearing property losses, public opinion has shifted toward harsher punishment. According to a Korea Gallup poll conducted in March among 1,002 adults nationwide, 81% responded that the upper age limit for juvenile offenders should be lowered from the current under 14. Only 13% opposed, and 6% were undecided. Among those in favor of lowering the age, the most common response was to lower it to "under 12," at 39%.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Proponents argue that the age criteria should be adjusted to reflect the physical and psychological maturity of youths, the increasing sophistication of criminal methods, and the use of juvenile offender status to repeatedly commit crimes. Opponents, however, claim that there is insufficient evidence of increased brutality in juvenile crime, and that simply lowering the age of criminal responsibility is unlikely to be effective in preventing recidivism. The National Assembly Legislative Research Service has also pointed out that, given the divided opinions on lowering the age for juvenile offenders, the necessity of the system, the purpose of juvenile justice, and actual crime trends should be thoroughly reviewed.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.