Semi-Automated Offside System Tracks Even the Tip of a Toe
Fairness Enhanced, but Questions Remain: "Who Will Protect Football’s Emotion?"

The 2026 FIFA World Cup in North and Central America featured a symbolic moment in which technology corrected a human referee's mistake. In the group stage match between the United States and Paraguay on June 13, the referee initially pulled out a yellow card for U.S. defender Tim Ream. However, after a Video Assistant Referee (VAR) review, it was confirmed that there had been no foul. Instead, it was Paraguay's Miguel Almiron who had engaged in simulation—commonly referred to as a "Hollywood action." Ream's yellow card was rescinded and a warning was instead given to Almiron. This was the first case in World Cup history in which VAR corrected a card issued to the wrong player.


In the USA vs Paraguay match, the referee is giving a warning to Miguel Almiron of Paraguay (center). The warning originally given to U.S. defender Tim Ream was overturned after a VAR review, marking the first-ever case in World Cup history where a 'Mistaken Identity' was corrected. Photo by AP/The Yonhap News

In the USA vs Paraguay match, the referee is giving a warning to Miguel Almiron of Paraguay (center). The warning originally given to U.S. defender Tim Ream was overturned after a VAR review, marking the first-ever case in World Cup history where a 'Mistaken Identity' was corrected. Photo by AP/The Yonhap News

View original image

For a long time, football was a sport governed by humans. Even referee mistakes were accepted as part of the game, and heated controversies over decisions became part of World Cup lore. However, as AI and sensor technologies penetrate deeper into the pitch, the very landscape of football is changing fundamentally.


In this World Cup, every ball and every toe is tracked by AI and sensors. Overhead cameras in the stadium analyze player movements in 3D, and sensors inside the ball record the exact moment it is touched. The offside decision is also computed by AI before being relayed to the VAR room and the referees. FIFA emphasizes that technology maximizes fairness, but at the same time, many worry that "sports are gradually becoming a game of machines."

How Does AI Detect Offsides First?

The advanced Semi-Automated Offside Technology (SAOT) system works by using dedicated cameras installed underneath the stadium roof to track the main joint positions of players in real time, while sensors inside the ball capture the precise moment a pass is made.

[Reading Science] The Era of AI Referees: Will World Cup Decisions Become Fairer? View original image

AI combines these data streams to simultaneously calculate when the ball leaves the foot, the position of the attacking player's body, and the coordinates of the defensive line. In the past, VAR referees would pause the video and manually draw lines on the monitor to make a decision, but now AI instantly determines offside status and delivers the result to the referees.


FIFA has further streamlined the information transmission process between the semi-automated offside system and the referees in this tournament. In clear offside situations, the AI directly signals the referees, minimizing delays in decision-making. This is intended to reduce unnecessary fatigue and injury risk for players by cutting down the time play continues after an offside occurs.


The key to this speed lies inside the official match ball. Recent World Cup match balls are equipped with inertial measurement unit (IMU) sensors that record subtle movements and every touch of the ball hundreds of times per second. Although it appears to be an ordinary soccer ball, in reality, it is a highly precise data collection device rolling across the pitch.

The "Toe-Line Offside" Controversy: Fairness Versus Emotion

Referees are conducting a VAR review during the USA-Paraguay match. FIFA is operating both a semi-automated offside system and advanced VAR technology in this tournament. Photo by AP/The Yonhap News Agency

Referees are conducting a VAR review during the USA-Paraguay match. FIFA is operating both a semi-automated offside system and advanced VAR technology in this tournament. Photo by AP/The Yonhap News Agency

View original image

Paradoxically, as technology becomes more sophisticated, controversies over decisions have intensified. A prime example is the so-called "toe-line offside." AI decisions can accurately capture differences of just a few centimeters that are nearly impossible for the human eye to discern. Moments that would have previously gone unnoticed by referees or been lost in the flow of the game are now invariably judged as offside.


Bochan Kim, Professor of AI Sports Analysis at Daekyung University, said, "Offside decisions often have a direct impact on match results, so precise judgments are essential. Although it can interrupt the flow of the game, the benefits of reducing clear errors and increasing trust in decisions are greater."


However, for humans who consume football, emotions have become more complicated. Instead of celebrating freely after a goal, players and fans now anxiously watch for a VAR check message on the scoreboard—a sight that has become commonplace. While technology has reduced errors, it is also blamed for taking away some of the spontaneity and immersion of the game.


Sungchan Hong, Professor of Sports Exercise Science at Seoul Women's University, pointed out, "Accurate decisions via VAR are essential, but if reviews take too long, they can break up the flow of the game and decrease player concentration. There needs to be a balanced approach, using advanced technology with precision especially for incidents that decisively affect the outcome, such as goals."

AI Is Not Perfect

The AI-based Semi-Automatic Offside Technology (SAOT) analyzes player positions in three dimensions to determine offside decisions. At this World Cup, while AI decision technology was praised for reducing refereeing errors, criticisms arose regarding system malfunctions and controversy over "toe-end offside" calls. The photo is a captured scene from the UK BBC broadcast criticizing the SAOT system for ruling a player offside despite the system not being offline. Photo by AP/Yonhap News

The AI-based Semi-Automatic Offside Technology (SAOT) analyzes player positions in three dimensions to determine offside decisions. At this World Cup, while AI decision technology was praised for reducing refereeing errors, criticisms arose regarding system malfunctions and controversy over "toe-end offside" calls. The photo is a captured scene from the UK BBC broadcast criticizing the SAOT system for ruling a player offside despite the system not being offline. Photo by AP/Yonhap News

View original image

Human referees cannot capture every situation on the pitch in a split second. In contrast, AI systems analyze multi-camera footage without blind spots and calculate the positions of multiple players in real time.


However, the technology is not without flaws. In the Switzerland-Qatar group stage match of this World Cup, a technical malfunction related to VAR occurred, prompting FIFA to issue an official explanation after the match. The semi-automated offside decision graphics were not broadcast correctly, preventing viewers from checking the basis for the decision.


European media, including the BBC, raised concerns about the transparency of the decision-making process, stating, "It is impossible to know what evidence AI used to reach its conclusion." This case demonstrated that technology introduced to enhance fairness could paradoxically become a new source of mistrust. It also highlighted that while AI can calculate coordinates and moments of physical contact, it cannot interpret the overall context of the match.


Professor Kim commented, "In areas requiring objective measurements, such as offside, technology should be actively used. However, aspects like the intent behind a foul, the severity of cards, and the art of game management should remain the domain of human referees. In the future, the role of the human referee will become that of a final manager who comprehensively interprets and takes responsibility for the information provided by technology within the context of the match."

Data Becomes Football's New Power

Modern football has already evolved into a massive data industry. Europe’s major clubs analyze player movement range, pressing intensity, passing networks, and stamina expenditure in real time. These accumulated data are used not only for tactical adjustments during matches but also for player recruitment, predicting injury risks, and long-term condition management.

[Reading Science] The Era of AI Referees: Will World Cup Decisions Become Fairer? View original image

This is why fans at home can now view real-time data such as shot speed, pass completion rate, and expected goals (xG) on broadcast screens. Football has become a high-tech industry, analyzed by thousands of data points.


Professor Kim explained, "Modern sports science teams use physical data to assess player fatigue and predict injury risks early. Such quantitative data provide significant support for match preparation and team operations."


However, disparities in capital remain a challenge. Wealthy big clubs and football powerhouses amass more extensive data and build sophisticated, customized AI systems. On the other hand, smaller clubs or national teams with limited resources find it difficult to develop comparable digital infrastructure. This is why there are concerns that data and AI are creating a new "sports power hierarchy."


Nevertheless, Professor Kim stressed, "While gaps in data infrastructure can widen disparities between clubs, the sheer quantity of data does not guarantee victory. What matters is how well the data is interpreted and applied to actual situations."

Has Technology Made Football Fairer?

The introduction of advanced technology in football history has always been a hot-button issue. When goal-line technology (GLT) was first introduced, and later when VAR was adopted, there were fierce criticisms that it ruined football’s unique flow and romance. Yet, over time, these technologies have become part of the game.

[Reading Science] The Era of AI Referees: Will World Cup Decisions Become Fairer? View original image

AI officiating is following the same path. What is clear is that technology has reduced the egregious errors that can decide matches. Scenes like the one in the USA-Paraguay game, where a player was cleared of a wrongful accusation, show why technology belongs on the pitch. Professor Hong concluded, "The most important thing is to find a balance between accuracy and the flow of the game."



Football remains a human sport. While AI has become a new eye to reduce errors, interpreting the context of the match and taking final responsibility still rests with humans. This World Cup shows that it is not the beginning of an era where AI replaces referees, but rather a time when the referee’s role is being newly defined.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing