Industry: "Extend SPAC Lifespan, Allow Private Placements"
Regulators: "No Institutional Reforms Under Review... Quality Companies Must Go Public"
Some Argue Market Conditions Matter More Than Policy Changes

Editor's NoteA Special Purpose Acquisition Company (SPAC) was once seen as a new route for unlisted companies to go public and as a supplementary vehicle for venture capital exits. However, with the recent surge in failed mergers and delistings, concerns over a shrinking SPAC market are growing. On the other hand, some argue that SPACs are still serving as a gateway for small and mid-sized growth companies to go public. The Asia Business Daily will explore, in a three-part series, the current state of the SPAC market, the structure of the venture capital exit market, and the policy challenges of balancing investor protection and market revitalization.

As the SPAC merger success rate has sharply declined, there is a clear divide in opinions regarding the activation of the SPAC market and the strengthening of regulations. The financial investment industry claims that streamlining the review process and easing regulations on capital raising are necessary to revitalize SPACs, while financial authorities are firmly focused on preventing insolvency to protect investors.


SPACs No Different from Direct Listings... Industry Calls for Institutional Improvements Such As Private Placements and Extension of SPAC Lifespan

[SPAC in Crisis ③] "Easing or Regulation?"... SPAC Policy at a Crossroads View original image

According to the Korea Exchange on June 24, between 2021 and April this year, the average review period for SPAC merger listings was 110 days, which is not significantly different from the 117 days required for a KOSDAQ listing. Considering that SPAC mergers do not have the long review periods associated with special cases on KOSDAQ, the review for SPAC merger listings is considered even more stringent.


An official from the venture capital (VC) industry pointed out, "A SPAC is a supplementary device that broadens exit options, but the review process is as rigorous as a direct listing. If the review burden is similar, companies will inevitably choose direct listings, which have higher valuations and more visibility."


For SPACs to serve as a complement in the Korean venture investment environment, which is heavily dependent on direct listings, the high barrier to listing needs to be lowered. Industry experts agree that extending the lifespan of SPACs is an urgent measure. Currently, SPACs have a lifespan of three years, and if they do not complete a merger within three years after listing, they are delisted and dissolved.


A VC executive noted, "In a prolonged market downturn and period of high external uncertainty like now, it is very difficult in practice to find a suitable merger target and complete the review process within such a short timeframe of three years. Extending the SPAC lifespan is the most realistic alternative to ultimately increase the merger success rate," he said.

[SPAC in Crisis ③] "Easing or Regulation?"... SPAC Policy at a Crossroads View original image

There are also calls to allow listed companies to conduct private investment in public equity (PIPE) transactions. PIPE transactions involve a publicly listed company selling its securities privately to institutional and other professional investors. In Korea, PIPEs for SPACs have been effectively prohibited as they require a special resolution at the shareholders' meeting. Some argue that this should be changed to require only a board resolution instead.


A VC investment manager explained, "If private placements become possible in SPACs, the influx of institutional capital would bring a certification effect, raising the likelihood of successful mergers, and it would also help secure stable funding for R&D and other needs of the merged company. In the United States, SPAC mergers frequently occur in deep-tech sectors such as artificial intelligence (AI) and quantum computing, where large amounts of capital are commonly raised through PIPE structures."


Regulators: "Preventing Insolvency Comes First"... U.S. SEC's Post-Merger Regulatory Trends Also a Burden

On the other hand, financial authorities have drawn a clear line regarding the possibility of easing regulations. Their concern is that SPAC deregulation could be abused as a backdoor for insolvent companies to go public, harming retail investors. A financial authority official said, "There is nothing under review at the moment. Before any institutional reforms, our priority is to ensure that investors are presented with proper, high-quality products and to maintain a rigorous screening function."


[SPAC in Crisis ③] "Easing or Regulation?"... SPAC Policy at a Crossroads View original image

This cautious stance is in line with global regulatory trends. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has strengthened post-merger regulation by removing forward-looking performance disclosures from civil liability exemptions for SPAC listings, thereby holding them to the same standard of legal responsibility as direct listings. This move comes after a series of bankruptcies among companies whose shares plummeted after SPAC mergers.


For example, Nikola, a U.S. electric vehicle (EV) truck startup that merged with a SPAC in June 2020, saw its share price plunge repeatedly and ultimately filed for bankruptcy in February last year, resulting in its delisting from Nasdaq. The founder of Nikola was also sentenced to prison for fraud in December 2023 after excessively exaggerating the company's technology and performance.


Meanwhile, some argue that market conditions are more important than institutional reforms for SPACs. An investment bank (IB) official explained, "SPAC mergers are most influenced by macroeconomic conditions. During bull markets, companies are drawn to traditional IPOs to maximize their valuations, while in downturns, SPACs are chosen to overcome listing hurdles. Therefore, the current stagnation is more a matter of economic timing than institutional flaws."




<End of three-part series>

[SPAC in Crisis] ① "Even After 3 Years, No Merger" ... SPAC Market Faces Wave of Liquidations

[SPAC in Crisis] ② Tighter IPO Reviews Cause SPAC Bottleneck ... Need for Diversification of Exit Markets


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing