The IT Investment Boom of the 1990s Raised Productivity
Economic Indicators Adjusted Retroactively, Growth Rate Revised Upward

"Underestimated Growth, Overestimated Inflation"... The Pitfalls of Economic Indicators in the Age of AI View original image

With productivity being revised upward in the era of artificial intelligence (AI), some analysts argue that traditional frameworks for interpreting economic indicators may no longer be appropriate. They advise that, especially in the early stages of adopting new technologies, economic growth rates tend to be underestimated, while inflationary pressures are often overestimated, and these factors should be interpreted with caution.


On June 23, Kim Yong, a researcher at NH Investment & Securities, analyzed that the current phase of AI-driven growth bears similarities to the IT investment boom of the 1990s. From 1990 to 1998, Korea’s gross domestic product (GDP) growth rates were revised upward by an average of 0.6 percentage points per year following a statistical revision in 1998–1999.

"Underestimated Growth, Overestimated Inflation"... The Pitfalls of Economic Indicators in the Age of AI View original image

Kim explained that this could be attributed to the boom created by the IT sector. He noted that 75% of the increase in labor productivity in the late 1990s was due to the IT sector. Considering that IT is a general-purpose technology, productivity gains in non-IT sectors were also closely linked to IT advancements. Ultimately, the upward revision of overall labor productivity growth rates in hindsight was essentially due to the IT sector.


Kim argued that a similar pattern could emerge this time as well. In particular, expenditures related to AI could be reclassified as capital investment. Spending on proprietary data refinement, prompt libraries, AI model development, and internal evaluation systems, previously treated as expenses, could be recognized as capital investments. Data capitalization is expected to be reflected in GDP figures around 2030, but a considerable portion is currently estimated. The U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis projects that data capitalization could raise the average annual GDP growth rate by about 0.07 percentage points. If broader categories of intangible investments related to AI are considered, the adjustment could be even larger.

"Underestimated Growth, Overestimated Inflation"... The Pitfalls of Economic Indicators in the Age of AI View original image

He also emphasized that the development of an AI software price index could further raise real growth rates. Real GDP is calculated using a price index known as a deflator, which can introduce distortions when new industries experience rapid growth. Since new products have no comparable predecessors for price comparison, quality changes are measured and reflected in the price index instead.


When the sharp rise in software prices over the past four months is annualized, it translates to a 73% surge. Taking improvements in AI performance into account, growth rates could be revised upward by 0.1 to 0.3 percentage points annually. The adoption of a quality-adjusted price index for computers already contributed to an average annual increase of 0.25 percentage points in real growth rates between 1995 and 1999.

"Underestimated Growth, Overestimated Inflation"... The Pitfalls of Economic Indicators in the Age of AI View original image

Estimates of potential growth rates in the 1990s were continuously revised upward over time. GDP growth rates announced in the late 1990s fell below or were close to real interest rates. However, the reality was different. In 1995, when a soft landing was a major concern, the growth rate appeared to be 1.3 percentage points lower than the average real interest rate, but in fact, the gap was only 0.6 percentage points. From 1996 onward, growth rates outpaced real interest rates.



Kim diagnoses that in the early stages of adopting new technologies such as AI, economic indicators may show a tendency for growth rates to be underestimated and inflationary pressures to be overestimated. He explained, "This means the economy can withstand higher real interest rates than the indicators suggest. However, while higher growth rates tend to push up interest rates, falling prices tend to lower them, which could narrow the range for policy rate adjustments."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing