Former Cleavy CEO Yoonkyung Jeon: "Final Legal Judgment Still Pending... Brand Headquarters Must Show Responsible Attitude"
"The Real Battlefield Is the Luxembourg Court"
"I do not see this matter as simply a dispute between companies, but rather as a question about the responsibilities that brand headquarters and domestic business operators have toward consumers and the market."
Yoonkyung Jeon, former CEO of Cleby Co., Ltd., who is currently involved in a dispute over the domestic trademark rights for Marithe Francois Girbaud, shared this perspective when asked about her thoughts on the current situation.
She stated, "A brand's value stems not from short-term interests, but from trust built with consumers over a long period of time," adding, "What is needed now is not a unilateral declaration of victory or stigmatization of the other party, but rather a responsible response that respects the ongoing legal procedures, minimizes consumer confusion, and restores trust in the market."
On June 18, we met with the former CEO Jeon to ask about the background of the trademark dispute and her plans going forward.
The following is a Q&A with former CEO Jeon.
-What made you decide to do this interview?
▲There has been a lot of reporting and many different interpretations regarding the recent trademark dispute, but I felt that the spread of speculative content and one-sided claims without sufficient fact-checking was increasing confusion among the market and consumers. Since I have mainly engaged in business and activities overseas, there were practical limitations to responding immediately to various issues that arose in Korea. However, I decided to participate in this interview in order to more accurately explain the ongoing legal procedures and the actual situation, and to reduce confusion.
-What are your thoughts on the current domestic situation?
▲Some media outlets have reported as if all legal disputes regarding the trademark rights have concluded, but in reality, important legal procedures—including the main lawsuit currently underway in Luxembourg—are still ongoing. Since a final legal decision has not been made regarding the double contract issue by the brand headquarters, Wurzburg, it is very important to exercise caution when designating a particular business operator as the rightful owner or, conversely, labeling the other party as a counterfeit company or unauthorized operator.
On February 21, 2023, in Paris, France, Yoonkyung Jeon, former CEO of Cleavy Corporation, is reviewing the exclusive domestic use contract before signing it with the couple François Joubert (left) and Marité Baschlerhi (right). Provided by former CEO Yoonkyung Jeon
View original image-Does this mean Cleby is also a legitimate domestic distributor?
▲I signed a license agreement with the brand headquarters, Wurzburg, through a legitimate procedure on February 21, 2023, and have conducted business accordingly. The current lawsuit is also a process to clearly confirm these rights. It is not desirable to portray Cleby Co., Ltd. as if it were operating illegally or to give consumers the wrong impression, especially when no final legal judgment has been made.
-You lost both the preliminary injunction and the first trial in the trademark lawsuit in the domestic courts.
▲After signing the license agreement, I implemented a co-CEO system at Cleby to ensure more stable management of the domestic business. Subsequently, the then-co-CEO, Mr. Lee, effectively exercised exclusive control over company management, leading to internal disputes. I believe this caused confusion in the submission of documents and responses related to the lawsuit. I also think the court’s decision to grant the injunction was made without fully reflecting Cleby’s position and the key issues at stake.
However, these internal management disputes at Cleby and the current license dispute are separate matters. After the recent dismissal of Mr. Lee from both the board of directors and the CEO position, I have formed a new legal team consisting of expert attorneys to actively respond to lawsuits both domestically and internationally. The core of the current dispute concerns the contract and rights relationship established by the brand headquarters. The license agreement in question designates the Luxembourg court as the court of exclusive jurisdiction. Ultimately, the substantive truth and final legal determination of rights in this matter will be decided through the main lawsuit currently ongoing in Luxembourg.
-There is consumer confusion over the 'counterfeit controversy.'
▲What concerns me most is the confusion among consumers. I saw an article recently in which Layer mentioned forming a group for victims. I fully understand and respect consumers’ concerns and complaints. However, since legal determinations regarding the rights and contractual relationships are still ongoing both domestically and internationally, I believe responsibility for these issues must also be established based on sufficient fact-checking and legal judgment. If there is actual consumer damage, the cause and responsibility for such damage must also be objectively and fairly determined. The brand headquarters must also fully recognize the confusion occurring in the domestic market and take a more responsible role in terms of consumer protection and market stability.
On February 21, 2023, in Paris, France, Jeon Yoonkyung, former CEO of Clevey Corporation (third from the left), who signed a domestic exclusive use contract with François Jaubert and Marité Basclerc, is shaking hands with François Jaubert. Photo by former CEO Jeon Yoonkyung
View original image-Where do you think the responsibility for this situation lies?
▲At the root of this issue is the double contract signed by the brand headquarters. Nevertheless, the brand headquarters has so far prioritized its business relationship with a particular operator rather than actively resolving the confusion caused by its own contracts. As a result, even though controversy and confusion over rights continue in the domestic market, the brand headquarters has not taken a more active approach to resolving the problem, and I find this very disappointing.
-How do you hope this issue will be resolved?
▲I believe that the brand headquarters should not simply consider its own economic interests but should demonstrate a more responsible attitude toward the problems arising from its contracts. I do not wish to attack a particular operator or escalate conflicts. If necessary, I am fully prepared to communicate and negotiate with the brand headquarters to find ways to minimize consumer confusion and restore market stability. I will also do my utmost to reduce confusion for domestic consumers and partners and to help restore stability to the market.
-What are your future plans?
▲Should anyone take advantage of the current dispute to use the Marithe Francois Girbaud brand or the Cleby name without authorization or to conduct related business in a way that misleads others about their relationship with Cleby, I plan to verify the facts and take all necessary legal action, including civil and criminal proceedings. In addition, issues such as the priority right for business in China, domestic business rights, and various other rights relationships will also be clearly determined through ongoing litigation and legal procedures going forward.
The Marithe Francois Girbaud trademark, which is involved in a dispute over exclusive domestic usage rights.
View original image© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.