KIRA: "Emergency Room Non-Admittance Is a System Failure"
Calls for Resident Protection, Including Exemption from Criminal Liability

The emergency medicine community and resident organizations have voiced strong opposition after a physician and a medical resident were referred to prosecutors for allegedly refusing to accept a patient during an emergency room non-admittance fatality incident that occurred in Daegu three years ago.


(ChatGPT generated image)

(ChatGPT generated image)

View original image

The Korean Intern Resident Association (KIRA) issued a statement on the 19th, expressing “deep regret over the investigative authorities’ decision to refer medical staff—who were standing by at the scene despite structural limitations—to the prosecution,” and criticized the move as “a decision that extinguishes even the last hope for the future of medicine in Korea.”


KIRA pointed out, “The essence of emergency room non-admittance—where emergency patients cannot be accepted—lies not in the negligence or malice of individual medical staff, but in the exhaustion of supporting clinical capacity and the accumulation of failures in a distorted medical delivery system.” The association added, “Despite not having final authority over the hospital’s staffing or facilities, residents are at the front lines of patient care and are unfairly burdened with legal liability simply for being there,” and argued, “It is extremely harsh and unjust to hold young doctors, who remained at the scene that day, criminally responsible for such a structural disaster.”


KIRA urged, “Immediately stop setting a precedent of criminally punishing residents for deficiencies in hospital systems or infrastructure,” and called on the government to “expand supporting clinical capacity and ensure legal protection for residents so they can focus on saving patients’ lives in a safe environment, as a fundamental solution to the problem.”


Previously, the Korean Society of Emergency Medicine and the Korean Emergency Medicine Physicians Association also released separate statements on June 16, warning that, “While the government and medical community are working to resolve the so-called ‘emergency room ping-pong’ issue, this referral of physicians to prosecutors undermines public trust in emergency care and could foster misguided perceptions.”


The Korean Society of Emergency Medicine emphasized, “At the time of the incident, the Ministry of Health and Welfare conducted a thorough investigation and fully gathered feedback from the medical community, ultimately imposing only administrative measures on the hospital without referring individual physicians to the police or prosecutors.” “The prosecution must issue a non-indictment to avoid hampering the government and medical community’s efforts to resolve the emergency room ping-pong issue,” the association stressed.


The Korean Emergency Medicine Physicians Association also stated, “The decision to admit patients is not a simple administrative process but a highly specialized medical act that cannot be judged by judicial authorities.” The association strongly criticized, “If the medical judgment of frontline staff—who swiftly informed that admission was impossible—is treated as a crime, Korea’s emergency medical system will completely collapse.”



Earlier, the Daegu Metropolitan Police Agency referred two physicians to the prosecution without detention on charges of violating the Emergency Medical Service Act. They are accused of failing to promptly treat a 17-year-old girl, identified as ‘A,’ who was brought to the emergency room after falling from a four-story building in March 2023, and instead sending her to another hospital. One of the accused was a resident at the time of the incident and is currently serving as a military doctor.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing