Yonhap News

Yonhap News

View original image

Meritz Financial Group has strongly refuted the position of MBK Partners regarding support for the rehabilitation of Homeplus, stating that "the major shareholder is shifting the responsibility for management failure onto the creditors."


On June 19, Meritz Financial Group commented on the statement released by MBK Partners and Homeplus, saying, "They are gravely distorting the facts," and emphasized, "For the rehabilitation of Homeplus, the largest shareholder must provide responsible financial support and guarantees."


Meritz pointed out that the core issue in this situation is that the major shareholder, who has sufficient financial capacity, is transferring the responsibility for rehabilitation to the creditors.


The company argued, "MBK is a large asset manager that has grown by benefiting from the capital markets and private equity systems, but when it comes time to take responsibility for investment failures and poor management, it hides behind a non-transparent financial structure and avoids accountability."


They continued, "If MBK is confident in the possibility of Homeplus’s rehabilitation, there is no reason to refuse to provide payment guarantees. If they lack financial capacity, they should present objective evidence to prove it."


Meritz also disputed MBK’s claim of a "2.5 trillion won loss," arguing that this figure does not correspond to an actual economic loss. MBK has claimed that it recorded a loss of 2.5 trillion won due to its failed investment in Homeplus, but Meritz explained that this figure is based on writing off the book value of investment assets and does not mean that MBK actually lost the entire amount from its own equity.


According to Meritz, as of the end of last year, MBK Partners is estimated to have earned more than 4 trillion won in profits over the past decade through its four main funds (Funds 3, 4, 5, and 6).


In particular, Meritz revealed that Fund 3, which invested in Homeplus, achieved over 1 trillion won in profits despite the deterioration of Homeplus’s business performance.


Meritz further claimed that, during the management of these funds, MBK received approximately 300 million dollars in management fees and about 500 million dollars in performance fees, totaling 820 million dollars (about 1.23 trillion won) in compensation.


Meritz pointed out, "MBK’s description of bearing an economic loss of 2.5 trillion won from the Homeplus investment could mislead the market by greatly exaggerating the actual burden."


Meritz also refuted MBK’s claim that it provided 400 billion won to support the normalization of Homeplus. The company explained that, of the support amount cited by MBK, 200 billion won was a payment guarantee for interest on funds Homeplus raised from securities firms before filing for rehabilitation, and that the first (60 billion won) and second (100 billion won) rounds of emergency operating funds (DIP) were not direct cash injections but guarantees provided by MBK.


Accordingly, Meritz asserted that, after the commencement of rehabilitation, the actual cash injected by the major shareholder amounted to about 40 billion won, which was a personal contribution from Chairman Michael Kim.


Meritz stated, "Most of the 400 billion won in support cited by MBK is in the form of guarantees, and should be distinguished from actual cash injections."


Meritz also rejected MBK’s claim that "Meritz could earn excess profits through the liquidation of Homeplus."


The company explained, "Meritz’s goal is not the liquidation of Homeplus, but the normal recovery of claims through rehabilitation. If liquidation were to proceed, the recovery of principal and interest itself could become uncertain due to a decline in real estate value, tenant compensation claims, disposal costs, and a lengthy sale process."


They added, "MBK itself has mentioned the risks of liquidation in official correspondence to Meritz. The claim that Meritz could earn 516.1 billion won in excess profits by applying an annual 20% default interest rate based on a liquidation scenario is an unrealistic calculation."


Meritz stated that the provision of DIP financing is financial support that involves the risk of additional losses, and therefore requiring payment guarantees from MBK and Chairman Michael Kim is a necessary safeguard for financial institutions.



A company representative remarked, "The essence of the Homeplus situation lies not in the creditors’ recovery efforts, but in the major shareholder’s management failure and responsibility. Rather than misleading the market with liquidation logic or inflated numbers, MBK should acknowledge its responsibilities as a major shareholder and provide actual financial support and guarantees."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing