[Why&Next] Cost Pressure Drops Sharply... Nonghyup Distribution Survives on Life Support Amid 'Reckless Management'
Cumulative Borrowings from Nonghyup Bank Reach 130 Billion Won
Interest Expenses on General Borrowings Hit 3 Billion Won Last Year
Ongoing Operating Losses Intensify Interest Burden
Nonghyup Distribution, which operates Nonghyup Hanaro Mart, a specialty retailer of agricultural and food products, is enduring repeated poor performance thanks to financial support from its affiliate, Nonghyup Bank. Since the establishment of the integrated corporation in 2021, purchasing power has increased and cost pressures have decreased, but profitability has deteriorated due to a significant rise in fixed costs such as employee salaries. With the offline consumer market contracting and sales declining, the company is mired in a structural financial crisis, losing billions of won each year solely to interest payments on its borrowings.
According to the audit report Nonghyup Distribution submitted to the Financial Supervisory Service's electronic disclosure system on the 25th, the company renewed its agreements for temporary and overdraft loans with Nonghyup Bank last month, extending the borrowing period for a total of 50 billion won—20 billion won and 30 billion won for each loan, respectively—by one year.
Nonghyup Bank Loans Reach 130 Billion Won... Interest Burden Soars 1,400 Times in Five Years
The cumulative amount Nonghyup Distribution has borrowed from Nonghyup Bank now totals 130 billion won. As borrowings increased, interest expenses on general borrowings, which stood at around 2 million won in 2021, surged to over 3 billion won last year. Last year, operating losses ballooned to 30.5 billion won—about a 40% increase from the previous year—and nearly 10% of this loss was spent on annual interest payments alone.
This borrowing-driven management began in earnest after Nonghyup Economic Holdings, which owns 100% of Nonghyup Distribution, integrated four distribution subsidiaries (Nonghyup Distribution, Nonghyup Chungbuk Distribution, Nonghyup Daejeon Distribution, and Nonghyup Busan Gyeongnam Distribution) into Nonghyup Distribution in November 2021, excluding Nonghyup Hanaro Distribution, under the pretext of "enhancing management efficiency."
After the launch of the integrated corporation, sales increased only marginally, while operating losses continued, forcing the company to rely on borrowings to secure working capital.
Within Nonghyup, some have pointed to the fact that after the launch of the integrated corporation, Nonghyup Economic Holdings took over the authority to purchase agricultural products that had previously been held by each of the four companies. This shift left Nonghyup Distribution unable to take the lead in ordering inventory or running marketing promotions, reducing it to a mere sales window for products purchased by Nonghyup Economic Holdings.
Gross Margin Ratio Drops from 86% to 82%... Payroll Costs Are the Cause of Continued Losses
However, an analysis of Nonghyup Distribution's audit report by this publication revealed that the company's gross margin ratio has dropped significantly compared to before the integration. The gross margin ratio refers to the proportion of sales revenue that goes toward the cost of goods sold (such as product and manufacturing costs); a lower ratio means improved sourcing capabilities and stronger cost controls.
The real reason Nonghyup Distribution has remained mired in losses every year is an explosion in selling and administrative expenses, especially payroll, following the merger. The company’s SG&A expenses were around 170 billion won immediately before integration, but surged by 37% to over 250 billion won in the first year after integration, and have continued to rise annually. In particular, payroll expenses jumped from 69.9 billion won to 102.3 billion won. The number of employees only fell slightly from 2,294 in 2021 to 2,183 last year, indicating that while the integration was justified as a way to improve management efficiency, cost-cutting and restructuring efforts were lacking.
The worsening performance at Nonghyup Distribution was also raised during last year’s National Assembly audit. According to materials obtained by Assemblyman Jeong Heeyong (People Power Party, Goryeong, Seongju, Chilgok in North Gyeongsang Province) from the National Agricultural Cooperative Federation, half of Nonghyup Distribution’s stores were running at a loss. Assemblyman Jeong commented at the time, "Four consecutive years of losses and half of all stores being unprofitable are signs of structural weakness," and added, "Comprehensive management innovation is needed to adapt to changing consumer patterns."
Industry observers have noted that Nonghyup Distribution’s poor performance and mounting financial burden stem from its failure to respond to the ongoing shift of consumer spending to online markets. According to one industry insider, "Retail giants like Emart and Lotte Mart have redesigned stores, enhanced experiential elements, and strengthened offerings in ready-to-eat and non-food categories, but Hanaro Mart has failed to keep up with these trends, making it less attractive to consumers." The insider added, "Even when agflation or rising agricultural product prices occur, it is difficult for Hanaro Mart to leverage its advantage as a specialty retailer of agricultural goods."
Poor management results have led to a reduction in the mandatory support funds paid for the benefit of farmers. Under the Agricultural Cooperatives Act, Nonghyup Distribution is required to pay agricultural support project expenses each year, amounting to 2.5% of the average operating profit or sales from the previous three years. This money, paid in exchange for using the agricultural cooperative’s name, is used for projects such as revitalizing farm distribution and supporting and guiding National Agricultural Cooperative Federation members. As sales and profits have declined, the agricultural support project expenses paid by Nonghyup Distribution increased from 4 billion won in 2021 to 5.1 billion won the following year, but then decreased to 4.6 billion won in 2024 and 4.3 billion won last year.
This contrasts with Nonghyup Hanaro Distribution, which is also under Nonghyup Economic Holdings. While Nonghyup Hanaro Distribution transferred both purchasing authority and its online business to Nonghyup Economic Holdings in 2021 and continues to post annual losses of around 40 billion won, its agricultural support project expenses increased from 3.5 billion won in 2024 to 3.7 billion won last year. Although Nonghyup Hanaro Distribution’s sales fell more than 7% year-on-year to 1.1804 trillion won last year, its operating loss narrowed slightly to 38.9 billion won. During this period, SG&A expenses dropped by about 17.7 billion won to 262.2 billion won, while payroll decreased from 98 billion won to 90.5 billion won. Benefits and welfare expenses were also reduced from 36.9 billion won to 31.3 billion won, indicating the continuation of austerity measures since CEO Lim Youngsun took office in February last year.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
A Nonghyup Distribution official stated, "We are currently working to enhance the competitiveness of our core businesses in agricultural, livestock, and fisheries products by focusing on in-season produce and partnerships with production regions. At the same time, we are expanding sales channels through online platforms and striving to overcome difficulties through improved internal efficiency and employee efforts."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.