Multiple Fractures Diagnosed While in Immigration Detention Center
Medication Only Provided Despite Specialist's Recommendation for Surgery

Cases have been identified in which detainees at immigration detention centers suffered injuries requiring surgery but did not receive timely treatment, raising concerns over the need to improve the medical support system.


The National Human Rights Commission of Korea announced on June 19 that it had recommended to the Minister of Justice that two foreign detainees at an immigration detention center be allowed to receive the necessary surgical treatment at an outside hospital. Immigration detention centers are facilities where foreigners who have received deportation orders stay until they are repatriated to their home countries.


ChatGPT Generated Image

ChatGPT Generated Image

View original image

According to the petitioner, after injuring his foot during exercise time at the center and complaining of pain, he was only prescribed painkillers. Later, he injured his finger and was taken for medical examination at an outside hospital. An orthopedic specialist, based on MRI scan results, found multiple fractures in his hand and muscle and tendon injuries in his foot, and concluded that surgery was necessary. According to the petitioner, another detainee who was examined for a knee injury was diagnosed with a medial meniscus tear, and the specialist also determined that surgery was required.


The detention center stated that whether to provide outside medical treatment is determined by comprehensively considering the severity of the injury and the risk of escape. Regarding the petitioner, the center explained that necessary measures, such as prescribing medication, are taken each time he complains of pain. They also stated that additional examinations and the need for further treatment would be reviewed as his condition is monitored going forward.


The Human Rights Commission viewed as problematic the fact that medical specialists had determined surgery was necessary and the individuals involved have been suffering prolonged pain. In particular, the Commission noted that because immigration detention centers are facilities where personal freedom is restricted by administrative order, the state bears responsibility for protecting the health rights of detainees. The Commission emphasized that even foreigners undergoing deportation procedures must be able to receive necessary medical services in a timely manner, and, when surgery is required, must be guaranteed proper access to treatment.



A representative from the Commission stated, "If a medical specialist has determined that surgery is necessary, that professional judgment should be fully respected," and added, "Denying surgery may constitute a violation of health rights, so even while managing escape risks through identity verification or hospital checks, treatment must be guaranteed."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing