Yonhap News Agency

Yonhap News Agency

View original image

The penalty imposed on Kakao by the Fair Trade Commission for allegedly failing to properly inform users about early termination of its music streaming service has been ultimately canceled.


On June 18, the Seoul High Court's Administrative Division 3 (Presiding Judge Yoon Kangyeol) ruled in a remand trial for the lawsuit filed by Kakao against the Fair Trade Commission seeking the cancellation of corrective orders and the penalty payment order, stating, “The penalty payment order is hereby canceled.”


The court explained, “According to the Electronic Commerce Act, a penalty in lieu of business suspension can only be imposed if there is significant inconvenience caused to consumers. The mere fact that a company is split and the effectiveness of a business suspension is lost cannot be considered as grounds for imposing a penalty.” This follows the intent of the Supreme Court’s ruling in November last year, which sent the case back to the lower court.


In January 2024, the Fair Trade Commission imposed a corrective order and a penalty of 98 million won on Kakao, stating that from May 2017 to May 2021, while providing subscription-based music streaming services through Melon or KakaoTalk, the company failed to sufficiently inform users of the early termination function. Kakao had previously received a corrective order for similar violations, and according to standard procedure, would have been subject to a 'business suspension' penalty.


The issue arose after Kakao split off its digital music business to establish Melon Company, which was later merged back into a Kakao affiliate, resulting in a change of the business entity. The Fair Trade Commission determined that imposing a business suspension on Kakao headquarters would be ineffective, since business operations could in practice continue via the spun-off Melon entity, and thus chose to impose a penalty as an alternative sanction.


Kakao challenged this decision in court. In January last year, the Seoul High Court initially ruled in favor of the Fair Trade Commission, but the Supreme Court overturned this decision in November of the same year.


The Supreme Court emphasized that Article 34, Paragraph 1 of the Electronic Commerce Act must be interpreted strictly. The provision stipulates that penalties may only substitute for business suspension “when business suspension is likely to cause significant inconvenience to consumers.”



The Supreme Court stated, “Interpreting the law to include ‘cases in which the effectiveness of a business suspension as a sanction is lost due to a company split, etc.’ as grounds for imposing a penalty goes beyond the possible meaning of the text and violates the principle of prohibiting analogical interpretation.” However, the Supreme Court found the corrective order issued by the Fair Trade Commission itself to be legitimate and dismissed Kakao’s final appeal on that point.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing