Calls for Leadership Accountability in Both Major Parties After Local Elections
Concentration of Power in Party Leaders Since the Era of Military Dictatorship
The Need to Reexamine a System Dependent on Individual Leadership

[Inside Chodong] The Party Leader System, Now the Main Target of Infighting, Needs Reform View original image

After the June 3 local elections, strange developments have unfolded in the political arena. Both the Democratic Party of Korea and the People Power Party have been voicing their own claims of "defeat." While some of this may reflect acceptance of the public will or calls for self-reflection, there are underlying motives behind each side's declaration of "defeat." The real aim is to highlight the leadership's responsibility for the election outcome, driven by political objectives.


In fact, ever since the local elections, calls to hold Democratic Party leader Jeong Cheongrae and People Power Party leader Jang Donghyeok accountable have been raised almost daily, both inside and outside their respective parties. Many believe that Jeong, who is widely expected to seek another term, should not run again. Meanwhile, Jang, who pledged to seek a vote of confidence based on the election results, is now being pressed to keep his promise. Instead of asking "Where did the public sentiment in the local elections head?" the focus has shifted to "What should each party do about its leadership structure?"


Doesn’t this power struggle look familiar? Whether it has been the Democratic Party or the People Power Party, fierce battles over the party leadership have erupted at every major political juncture. The conflicts over party-government relations and the internal factional power struggles have been repeated, with only the main actors changing. Although replacing the party leader has often been presented as a solution to perceived problems, public expectations have never truly been met. If the same scenario continues to play out, it may be time to change the question: "Does the party leader system actually benefit our politics?"


In the history of Korean politics, parties have historically been structured around a single center of power—first under a "president" and more recently under a "party leader." Scholars trace this to the unique conditions faced by parties that had to resist military dictatorships. During the era of the "three Kims" (Kim Young-sam, Kim Dae-jung, and Kim Jong-pil), who helped establish a framework for party politics, all power was concentrated in the party president as a kind of wartime system to withstand government oppression. As a result, parties were run not through internal democracy, but at the discretion of the party president.


As political skills faded and "gaining power" became the sole priority, the core values parties should pursue were pushed aside. From morning public meetings onward, every message delivered by the parties focused on attacking and criticizing rival factions. "Being better at fighting"—in other words, combative skills—became the main qualification for party leadership. Those with the strongest fighting ability seized near-monarchical power and even took control of candidate nominations, securing dominance over the party.


In this process, cooperation and parliamentary principles have all but disappeared, and the constitutional duty of lawmakers—to act in the national interest and according to their conscience—has been crushed by partisan interests and hardline confrontational stances. Politics that emphasize "fighting skills" and prioritize nomination powers have become self-perpetuating, leaving no space for genuine politics and only room for endless conflict.



To break this cycle of repeated dysfunction, parties must modernize. Party lines and policies should be debated among party members, with platforms and policies chosen as a result of those discussions, and leaders selected based on their ability to achieve these goals. A culture of debate at the grassroots level and a bottom-up communication structure are needed, along with fundamental reflection on the "party leader system" that relies solely on the leadership of a single politician.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing