Abolition Debate Grows After Tourist Death
Seven Accidents Reported in the Past Year
Counterarguments: "Current Regulations Are Sufficient"

After an 18-year-old tourist fell and died while riding a carriage in New York's Central Park, public calls are mounting to completely ban carriage operations, which are considered a hallmark of New York.

The photo is not related to the specific content of the article. Pixabay

The photo is not related to the specific content of the article. Pixabay

View original image

According to The New York Times (NYT), New York police reported that at approximately 2:45 p.m. on June 17 (local time), Romanchi Mahajan, an 18-year-old tourist from India, fell from a carriage while riding in Central Park. She was transported to the hospital with severe injuries but ultimately died.


The accident occurred when the coachman briefly got off the carriage to take photos of the passengers. Suddenly, the horse, out of control, mounted the sidewalk and bolted across the lawn. As the horse rounded a corner, Mahajan fell out of the carriage. The carriage then collided with another carriage, overturned, and was completely destroyed.


A street vendor who witnessed the scene said, "The horse ran at a very fast speed," and added, "The coachman chased after the carriage but could not catch up."


Frequent Accidents and Deaths... Calls Grow for Carriage Ban

This accident has prompted animal rights activists to demand a halt to carriage operations in New York City.


The Central Park Conservancy stated that at least eight horse-related accidents have occurred in and around Central Park since May last year. Just last month, there was an incident where a horse crashed into another carriage and overturned it.


The controversy has intensified following the recent death of a carriage horse. On June 9, a horse named 'Deniz' collapsed and died while carrying passengers in Central Park. An initial autopsy revealed that Deniz had ingested toxic plants. As a result of this incident, animal protection groups and city council members have renewed discussions on banning carriage operations.


According to Humane World for Animals, at least four New York carriage horses have died since 2020. The Central Park Conservancy reported that in the past year alone, there have been at least seven incidents where horses became uncontrollable and posed a threat to passengers and pedestrians, or the coachman was injured, and has called for the abolition of carriage operations.



The photo is not related to the specific content of the article. Pixabay

The photo is not related to the specific content of the article. Pixabay

View original image

"Complete Ban Needed" vs "Current Regulations Are Sufficient"... Divided Opinions

As the controversy over carriage operations continues, related discussions are intensifying in the New York City Council.


The 'Ryder Act' is named after 'Ryder,' a horse that collapsed and was euthanized in the Hell's Kitchen area in August 2022. Representatives from animal rights organizations insist, "The congested traffic of New York is no place for horses," and are urging for a complete ban on carriage operations.


On the other hand, there is also strong opposition to a total ban, citing threats to the livelihoods of coachmen, many of whom are immigrants. John Samuelson, chairman of the Transport Workers Union (TWU), which represents the coachmen, argues that the current regulations are sufficient to protect horse welfare and calls for stronger management and oversight by city authorities.


Under current New York City regulations, carriage horses are allowed to work a maximum of nine hours per day and must receive at least five weeks of vacation each year. In addition, operations are prohibited when the temperature exceeds 31.7 degrees Celsius or falls below minus 7.8 degrees Celsius.



Meanwhile, just two days after the news of Deniz's death was reported, the city of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, enacted a complete ban on carriage operations, drawing even more attention to the future legislative direction of New York City.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing