Delivery Platform Industry Regrets Nullification of 360 Billion Won Mutual Growth Plan for Small Businesses
Consent Decree Application for Direct Support to Small Businesses Rejected
Baemin's 300 Billion Won and Coupang Eats' 60 Billion Won Mutual Growth Plans Back to Square One
The Fair Trade Commission has rejected the request to initiate the consent decree process submitted by Woowa Brothers and Coupang Eats, effectively nullifying a 360 billion won mutual growth support plan for small business owners. Industry insiders expressed disappointment that measures to provide swift and tangible support to small businesses were not accepted.
On June 18, Woowa Brothers stated in response to the Fair Trade Commission's decision to deny the initiation of the consent decree process, "We regret that the consent decree application, which aimed to rapidly restore market competition and directly support small business owners, has been dismissed." Coupang also commented, "Coupang Eats submitted a consent decree proposal that actively considered mutual growth with partner stores. We will diligently clarify our position throughout the upcoming review process."
The consent decree system allows a case to be resolved without determining the legality of alleged violations if a company voluntarily presents corrective measures and mutual recovery plans, subject to stakeholder feedback. Compared to lengthy legal procedures that determine whether to impose sanctions such as fines, this system enables victims to receive prompt and meaningful support and allows various mutual growth initiatives to be implemented.
Last month, Woowa Brothers applied to the Fair Trade Commission to initiate the consent decree process regarding three issues: "most-favored treatment demands," "preferential treatment for its own Baemin delivery service," and "misleading advertising of estimated delivery times." Coupang also applied for the consent decree process on the "most-favored treatment demands" issue. In their application, Woowa Brothers stated that they had proactively implemented corrective actions, including abolishing most-favored treatment demands, improving quality and settlement capabilities for store delivery services, and establishing equal exposure standards for store delivery and Baemin delivery services. Coupang Eats, through its consent decree application, also implemented corrective measures for suspected most-favored treatment violations, such as removing the "Wow Store" selection criteria and discontinuing policies linking the Wow Store system with free delivery benefits.
The industry has noted that both companies’ support plans for partner stores clearly demonstrated a strong commitment to mutual growth. Woowa Brothers proposed 51 billion won in delivery fee support over three years to improve the profitability of store delivery operators. To ease the burden on small business owners, the mutual growth plan included a three-year, 10 billion won program to reduce intermediary commission fees. These initiatives were to be funded through a 140 billion won mutual growth cooperation fund. In addition, the total scale of mutual growth support, including coupon cost support for all partner stores, amounted to 300 billion won. Coupang Eats also proposed a mutual growth support plan totaling 60 billion won, which included a mutual growth fund of approximately 40 billion won for commission and delivery fee support and easing burdens on small business owners. The industry views this as exceeding the anticipated fines.
The scale of mutual growth support proposed in the consent decree by Woowa Brothers and others is significant even compared to previous cases where consent decrees were finalized. In the first domestic consent decree case in 2014, concerning a portal operator's abuse of search monopoly power, the company offered a 100 billion won mutual growth support plan. In 2021, a foreign mobile phone manufacturer and, last year, a foreign platform company each had mutual growth support plans of 100 billion won and 30 billion won, respectively, accepted in their consent decree cases. An industry official stated, "Whereas previous cases mostly focused on building infrastructure or indirect support, the mutual growth plan for delivery apps included direct support measures such as commission and delivery fee reductions specifically for small partner stores."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Woowa Brothers explained, "The focus on alleviating burdens for small business owners stems from the core of the Fair Trade Commission’s corrective measures, which was ultimately to improve the profitability of partner merchants." They added, "Several organizations representing small business owners, including the Korea Federation of Micro Enterprise, the Korea Merchant Association, the Korea Foodservice Industry Association, the Korea Franchise Association, and the Korea Café Owners Cooperative, officially conveyed to the Fair Trade Commission their support for immediate and tangible support—rather than prolonged legal battles—being of the utmost urgency."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.