When Strikes Threaten the “Foundation of the Economy,” Politicians Step In
Now, They Push for Inefficient Investments to Win Votes
Factory Siting for Semiconductor Plants Should Be Left to Companies, Not Political Logic

[Reporter’s Notebook] Strikes Are Not Allowed, but Political Interference Is? View original image

"If there had been an abundance of electricity and water, why wouldn’t we have gone there already?"


The industry has shown clear signs of confusion regarding the proposal to build a new semiconductor plant in the Honam region. Until last year, Honam had never even been mentioned as a candidate site for a semiconductor factory. However, around the June local elections, calls to attract the plant began to gain momentum. As the political sphere took the initiative, welcoming the idea and treating it as a foregone conclusion, companies have found themselves in a situation where even denying or downplaying the proposal feels politically burdensome.


Under normal circumstances, it is the company that first assesses the feasibility of a factory site and then requests government approval. This is because, beyond electricity and water supply, a wide range of management variables must be considered—such as market demand, accessibility to equipment suppliers, the ecosystem for materials, parts, and equipment, as well as talent acquisition. For example, after SK hynix announced its investment plan for the Yongin semiconductor cluster in 2019, it took six years before actual construction began. Even when all procedures go smoothly, a semiconductor plant requires several years to materialize.


However, the push for a new facility in Honam is being discussed as if the location and schedule have already been decided, even though the company has not even properly completed its feasibility review. Amkor Technology, for instance, has already been operating a semiconductor packaging facility in Gwangju for decades. This is an example that demonstrates companies will make their own choices without political pressure if they deem the project economically viable. Currently, the political establishment has planted its flag first and is essentially pressuring companies to invest, reversing the normal order of things. When political logic takes precedence over industrial viability, there is a higher risk of inefficient decisions being made.


The irony is that it is the political sphere itself that is bringing about such inefficiencies. Just last month, during the crisis of a general strike at Samsung Electronics, both the government and political circles spoke with one voice, calling the semiconductor industry a national security asset and the backbone of the Korean economy, and moved to block the strike. They even mentioned or urged the invocation of emergency coordination powers, warning that a halt in semiconductor production lines could shake the national economy. The same government and politicians who emphasized the industry’s importance are now, under the banner of “voter sentiment” and “balanced regional development,” imposing inefficiency on companies.



If labor strikes that halt production lines restrain the national economy, then political pressure to determine factory sites without a thorough management feasibility review also restrains both companies and the national economy. If there is a genuine desire to revitalize the semiconductor ecosystem in Honam, political logic should be excluded, and the decision should be left to the companies.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing