Experts Say: "If Musk Is Determined, It's Hard to Stop"

"Following SpaceX's largest-ever initial public offering (IPO), it is anticipated that 'Elon Musk Incorporated' could be created through a merger with Tesla."


The New York Times (NYT) analyzed and reported on June 17 about these recent speculations on Wall Street. The NYT highlighted that SpaceX and Tesla have long shared executives and resources, and that they are jointly pursuing core artificial intelligence (AI) projects such as Terafab and Macrohard. Earlier this year, Tesla invested in xAI, the AI company headed by CEO Elon Musk that merged with SpaceX, and over the past two years, Tesla has sold hundreds of millions of dollars' worth of batteries and vehicles to SpaceX. Gwynne Shotwell, President of SpaceX, did not deny rumors of a merger in a recent interview with CNBC, saying, "Looking to the future, it's clear there are synergies between the two companies."

SpaceX logo. Photo by Reuters and Yonhap News

SpaceX logo. Photo by Reuters and Yonhap News

View original image

Experts predict that if the two companies merge, SpaceX—being the larger company by market capitalization—would likely exchange Tesla shares for its own stock. Under Texas law, two-thirds of Tesla shareholders must approve the merger. CEO Musk already holds about 20% of the voting rights. Many shareholders have demonstrated deep trust in Musk, even approving a $1 trillion compensation package for him. Tesla’s board also overlaps with some members from SpaceX, and many have longstanding relationships with Musk. For SpaceX, a merger would require approval from just one person—CEO Musk—who controls 82% of the company’s voting rights.


However, some have pointed out that since CEO Musk controls SpaceX and is also the largest shareholder of Tesla, a merger would essentially mean he is conducting a deal with himself. The NYT noted that this could lead to legal disputes on the grounds that it undermines the interests of other shareholders. Eric Talley, a professor at Columbia Law School, warned that if the acquisition terms favor SpaceX excessively, Tesla shareholders could push back.



Legal experts predict that if CEO Musk is determined to pursue a merger, it would be difficult to stop him regardless of legal action. Current Texas corporate law, where both Tesla and SpaceX are headquartered, requires investors to hold at least a 3% stake to challenge management’s decisions. Typically, only large investment firms meet this threshold. Even if minority shareholders band together, they would need to collectively hold $45 billion worth of stock, based on Tesla's market capitalization of about $1.5 trillion, making such a challenge highly unlikely.

"Musk's Next Move: Merger of SpaceX and Tesla" View original image

Regulatory authorities could theoretically raise antitrust concerns on the grounds that both companies are involved in AI businesses, or cite national security issues. However, Professor Talley believes that the administration of U.S. President Donald Trump is unlikely to oppose the merger. The NYT identified a drop in stock price as the biggest obstacle to the merger, but even this seems unlikely under current conditions. Charles Elson, director of the Weinberg Center for Corporate Governance at the University of Delaware, said, "In a bull market, everyone is generally satisfied because everyone is making money."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing