"Disclosure Requirements Should Be Strengthened to Ensure Appropriateness of Merger Value"
"Standards for Small-Scale Mergers Also Need to Be Revised"

There have been calls for strengthened disclosure requirements, the introduction of appraisal rights, and a mandatory tender offer system to protect the interests of minority shareholders in mergers and acquisitions (M&A).

On the 17th, attendees are taking photos at the seminar titled "Directions for Improving M&A Systems to Enhance Shareholder Value" held at the Financial Investment Center in Yeouido, Seoul. Photo by Seungwook Park

On the 17th, attendees are taking photos at the seminar titled "Directions for Improving M&A Systems to Enhance Shareholder Value" held at the Financial Investment Center in Yeouido, Seoul. Photo by Seungwook Park

View original image

On June 17 at the Financial Investment Center in Yeouido, Seoul, Hyunyoung Hwang, Research Fellow at the Korea Capital Market Institute, stated at a seminar on "Directions for M&A System Improvements to Enhance Shareholder Value," "Following three amendments to the Commercial Act and revisions to the Enforcement Decree of the Capital Markets Act, the next task is to protect shareholder interests in M&A processes where shareholder value could be undermined."


Research Fellow Hwang identified the strengthening of disclosure requirements, such as the submission of board opinion reports, as a key issue. She said, "Disclosures related to mergers should include detailed explanations from the board regarding the necessity of the transaction and the appropriateness of the merger value. For tender offers for delisting purposes, regulations should require disclosure of both the advantages and disadvantages, as is done in other countries."


She also called for systems to ensure fairness in cases where mergers could harm shareholders' interests. Research Fellow Hwang emphasized, "When shareholders, after reviewing the merger disclosure, determine that they will be disadvantaged, they should be able to exercise appraisal rights. Additionally, new systems should be considered, such as appointing external experts to evaluate the appropriateness of the merger value."


There was also criticism that the standards for small-scale mergers need to be revised. Small-scale mergers refer to those in which new shares are issued or treasury shares are transferred amounting to 10% or less of the surviving company's total issued shares, and are allowed without a general meeting of shareholders. Over 90% of mergers among listed companies are small-scale mergers, and dissenting shareholders cannot exercise appraisal rights. Research Fellow Hwang argued, "The criteria for small-scale mergers should be changed from the number of issued shares to net asset value," and that the system should be improved to allow for the granting of appraisal rights.

On the 17th, participants are speaking at the seminar on "Directions for Improving M&A Systems to Enhance Shareholder Value" held at the Financial Investment Center in Yeouido, Seoul. Photo by Seung-Wook Park

On the 17th, participants are speaking at the seminar on "Directions for Improving M&A Systems to Enhance Shareholder Value" held at the Financial Investment Center in Yeouido, Seoul. Photo by Seung-Wook Park

View original image

She went on to say, "The payment method for exercising appraisal rights also needs to be improved," adding, "If shareholders do not accept the company's proposed buyback price and request a court determination, it takes a minimum of 537 days and up to 3,925 days until a Supreme Court ruling is reached. Therefore, a system for advance payment of the buyback price is also necessary."


On the same day, Woochan Kim, Professor at Korea University Business School, raised the need to introduce a mandatory tender offer system for M&A. He stated, "The mandatory tender offer system is a mechanism that upholds the principle of equal treatment of shareholders by providing general shareholders with the same opportunity and price to sell as controlling shareholders when there is a change in control."


He directly refuted concerns that the introduction of such a system would shrink the M&A market. This is because cases are increasing where acquirers, such as in the cases of Osstem Implant and Lutronic, have offered general shareholders the same premium as controlling shareholders. Professor Kim explained, "The argument that the M&A market would contract due to increased acquisition costs assumes that the control premium is fixed, which is incorrect. If there is a willingness to close the deal, the premium will be adjusted downward, so there is no evidence that control transactions will decrease."


He also called for the establishment of specific criteria for an effective system. Professor Kim stated, "Considering the realities in Korea, the threshold for triggering a mandatory tender offer should be set at 25%, not 30%. In calculating the shareholding ratio, the total number of issued shares should exclude treasury shares so as to reflect actual control."


He emphasized the need to block so-called "lowballing," where the acquirer initially purchases shares at a high price but later acquires minority shareholders' shares at a lower price. Professor Kim suggested, "The period for calculating the tender offer price should be extended from the past six months to twelve months, and if less than 50% of shareholders accept the offer, the acquisition should be invalidated. Additionally, only cash purchases, not share swaps, should be permitted under the mandatory tender offer system."



Meanwhile, there were also calls to ease regulations to make it easier to delist companies if a mandatory tender offer system is implemented. Cheolmin Lee, CEO of VIG Partners, remarked, "If delisting is made difficult in the presence of dissenting shareholders while a mandatory tender offer system is in place, it increases uncertainty for private equity funds (PEFs). Since there will always be dissenting shareholders in M&A, Korea should consider allowing delisting via board resolution, as is the case in the United States."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing