[Policy Pulse] Beyond Greetings to Giving... Time to Redesign the Hometown Love Donation Program
Benchmarked from Japan's Furusato Nozei System
Donations Exceed 12 Trillion Won—80 Times Korea's Total
Despite 151.5 Billion Won Raised Last Year, Fiscal Impact Remains Minimal
Urgent Need to Expand Deduction Rates and Donation Limits
The heads of local governments elected through the nationwide simultaneous local elections on June 3 are now preparing for the launch of new local administrations. As they form transition committees and draw up action plans to fulfill the campaign pledges they made as candidates, they will inevitably come to realize the fiscal limitations of local governments. They will also find that funding for new projects is essential, but the resources that local government heads can independently secure are extremely limited.
However, there is a system in place that local governments can utilize as a creative fiscal strategy, yet it is not being fully leveraged. The Hometown Love Donation Program was introduced by benchmarking Japan's Furusato Nozei (hometown tax donation) system and has been fully implemented since 2023. Last year, the amount raised through the Hometown Love Donation Program reached 151.5 billion won, an increase of about 130% compared to the 65.1 billion won in its first year of implementation in 2023.
The Hometown Love Donation Program has shown rapid growth and is considered to have established itself well within just three years of its introduction. However, Yeongdeok County, which suffered from wildfire damage, raised the largest amount among counties at 3.7 billion won, but this accounted for only 0.37% of Yeongdeok County's 2023 budget of 989.7 billion won. The average amount raised in the 89 regions experiencing population decline was 760 million won, which demonstrates how limited the program's impact is on expanding local fiscal resources.
The total amount donated through Japan's hometown tax donation system, which served as the benchmark for Korea's Hometown Love Donation Program, is projected to reach 1.2727 trillion yen in the 2024 fiscal year. This exceeds 12 trillion won, which is about 80 times the amount raised by Korea's program. The Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications website discloses donation rankings and amounts for each local government, and the average amount raised by the top 20 local governments reaches 12.7 billion yen. Considering that the size and budgets of Japanese municipalities are generally smaller than those in Korea, the impact of the hometown tax donation system on bolstering the finances of Japan's less developed local governments is even more significant.
Why does such a gap exist? Although it is called a "tax" in name, Japan's hometown tax donation system is essentially a donation program that allows taxpayers to contribute directly to local governments. While only part of a typical donation is tax-deductible, with the hometown tax donation, the entire donation amount—except for 2,000 yen—is eligible for a tax deduction. For donors, the combination of the tax deduction and return gifts means there is virtually no economic burden, which encourages widespread participation in the system. Through this mechanism, taxpayers who have moved to cities can give back to their hometowns, where they benefited from education and welfare, without incurring any real cost.
In Korea, as its name implies, the Hometown Love Donation Program is fundamentally about individuals making donations out of affection for their hometowns. Donations up to 100,000 won are fully tax-deductible and come with return gifts, so the actual burden is essentially zero. However, for amounts above 100,000 won, only 16.5% is tax-deductible, which significantly increases the donor's out-of-pocket cost. According to statistics released by the Ministry of the Interior and Safety, a staggering 98.4% of donors last year gave 100,000 won or less. To raise the average donation amount of 760 million won in a region with a declining population, more than 7,000 donors would be needed.
Whereas Japan's hometown tax donation system serves as a horizontal fiscal adjustment mechanism that transfers tax revenue from major cities to rural areas, Korea's Hometown Love Donation Program is closer to a tax benefit system for donations. The original idea behind the hometown tax was to allocate a portion of local income tax to underdeveloped regions, but during the process of developing the system, it was changed to a tax deduction method for income tax. As a result, the system's function as a fiscal adjustment tool for balanced regional development has been significantly weakened.
The dramatic growth of Japan's hometown tax donation system can be attributed to proactive institutional innovation. The Japanese government has expanded the base of participation by introducing a corporate version that provides tax incentives for company donations, a crowdfunding model, and a corporate version involving talent dispatch. Local governments have attracted donors with unique return gifts that reflect local characteristics, such as the drift ice experience in Monbetsu City, Hokkaido, or soy-marinated salmon roe from Shiranuka Town. As institutional innovation and creative regional competition combined, the scale of donations increased explosively.
The current Hometown Love Donation Program in Korea was designed excessively conservatively, mainly out of concern for issues that arose in Japan, such as the outflow of tax revenue from Tokyo and metropolitan areas and overheated competition over return gifts. Representative examples include a reduction in the tax deduction rate, restrictions on return gifts, and a ban on corporate donations. As a result, although the negative side effects experienced by Japan's hometown tax system have been mitigated, the program's core benefits—expanding taxpayer choice in local tax allocation and helping address regional extinction—have also been weakened.
Experience the drift icebreaker ship in Monbetsu City, Japan. It is a tourist product that allows you to directly encounter drift ice in winter and serves as a hometown tax return gift. Monbetsu City is recognized as one of the top regions in Japan for hometown tax donations with return gifts that utilize local characteristics. Provided by Hokkaido Tourism Agency
View original imageThe Hometown Love Donation Program must be redesigned to achieve its original objectives. Even under the current framework, increasing the deduction rate and donation cap above 100,000 won and allowing corporate participation would further vitalize the program. Designated donation projects could expand national participation and heighten interest in local areas through nationwide contests and promotion via broadcast media and social networking services (SNS). More fundamentally, residents should be allowed to allocate a portion of their local income tax to a local government of their choice. Since local income tax is heavily concentrated in the Seoul metropolitan area and major cities, the hometown tax system could serve as a practical tool for fiscal decentralization by alleviating excessive tax revenue concentration in these areas.
The Hometown Love Donation Program should not remain merely a donation scheme to support one's hometown. It must evolve into a fiscal adjustment mechanism that connects metropolitan resources to local areas, and into a regional development platform that promotes local specialties, culture, and tourism resources nationwide. Donations should drive the revitalization of local industries and attract tourists, which would in turn reinvigorate the region in a virtuous cycle. This is why a redesign of the program is urgently needed amid the overconcentration in metropolitan areas and the looming crisis of regional extinction.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Byun Chang-heum, Professor of Public Administration at Sejong University and former Minister of Land, Infrastructure and Transport
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.