"Utterly Catastrophic," Critics Say
Republicans Hold Back Open Criticism but Express Concerns

The Wall Street Journal (WSJ) reported on June 16 (local time) that hardline conservative figures in the United States, who initially supported U.S. President Donald Trump at the outbreak of the war with Iran, are now turning their backs on him and expressing strong opposition following the ceasefire agreement.


Those who were once unwavering loyalists to President Trump are now concerned that the current ceasefire agreement fails to sufficiently deter Iran’s nuclear development and could provide the Iranian regime with economic breathing room, enabling it to rebuild its missile and military capabilities. Some have also voiced dissatisfaction that the Trump administration has not yet released the full text of the ceasefire agreement announced by President Trump on June 14.

U.S. President Donald Trump. Photo by Reuters Yonhap News

U.S. President Donald Trump. Photo by Reuters Yonhap News

View original image

Jack Keane, former Army General who advised President Trump privately throughout the Iran war, appeared on Fox News on June 15 and said, "Some of the statements coming from the Trump administration, as conveyed by reliable sources, are simply incomprehensible." Marc Thiessen, who served as chief speechwriter for former President George W. Bush, described the ceasefire agreement coverage as "utterly catastrophic." Both individuals provided private counsel to President Trump throughout the war with Iran.


Conservative commentator Ben Shapiro remarked, "If the President signed a bad deal, many people who supported him and viewed his actions on Iran as heroic will be deeply disappointed," adding, "In basketball, it’s not enough to win the first half. You have to finish the game."


The Iran war has dragged down President Trump’s approval ratings and created rifts even among his supporters. Tucker Carlson and Megyn Kelly, prominent conservative podcasters who had been among his most steadfast backers, criticized the Iran war as a betrayal of America First foreign policy, swayed by Israel. After receiving public rebuke from President Trump, they have been effectively ostracized from the MAGA (Make America Great Again) base, which forms Trump’s core support group. WSJ noted that the ceasefire negotiations could cause even the hardline conservatives who supported Trump throughout the war to turn against him.


Although open criticism has been restrained, concerns have surfaced within the Republican Party as well. Senator Lindsey Graham of South Carolina said he wants to review the preliminary agreement in person. Senate Republican Whip John Thune of South Dakota stated that Senate Republicans have requested the administration provide the full text of the agreement as well as related briefings.


The main issue raised by hardline conservatives is whether President Trump’s stated war objectives have been sufficiently achieved. While Trump claims the Iranian regime has been weakened, critics point out that the unconditional surrender of Iran, promised at the outset of the war, has not been realized. Conservative radio host Erick Erickson said, "They (the Trump administration) won militarily against Iran, but now they’re prepared to surrender at the negotiating table."


WSJ reported that even pro-Israel columnists and podcasters, who have spent months defending President Trump from criticism from the right, are now expressing concerns. They argue that President Trump is uninterested in achieving lasting peace in the Middle East, which could only come from forcing Iran to capitulate, and is instead focused solely on attracting media attention.



On June 19, Vice President JD Vance will visit Switzerland to sign the ceasefire memorandum of understanding (MOU). Shapiro warned, "The American people do not like war, but they hate losing even more," adding, "If this agreement is perceived as a defeat for the United States and the Vice President is seen as the mediator, the political backlash will be significant."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing