[Why&Next] Employment Retention Subsidy Doubles Recipients, But Benefit Amount and Duration Drop Sharply
Duration Reduced from 2.5 to 2.1 Months, Subsidy per Person Drops from KRW 1.17 Million to KRW 850,000
"Concerns Over Diluted Effectiveness as Program Becomes Permanent"
This year, while the number of recipients eligible for employment retention subsidies has more than doubled, both the duration and amount of benefits per person have decreased. As the scope of support widens but the amount per individual decreases, concerns are being raised about the weakened effectiveness of employment retention subsidies as a practical employment safety net.
According to the Ministry of Employment and Labor on June 22, the total number of people eligible for government employment retention subsidies this year, combining the main budget and the supplementary budget, stands at 48,000. This figure is more than double (an increase of 100.7%) compared to last year's 24,000. However, the total budget is KRW 8.89 billion (KRW 7.03 billion in the main budget and KRW 1.86 billion in the supplementary budget), marking only a 26.6% increase from the previous year's KRW 7.02 billion. The average support period used for budget calculation has decreased by 16.0%, from 2.5 months last year to 2.1 months this year, and the average subsidy per person has decreased by 27.3%, from KRW 1,175,000 to KRW 854,000.
The employment retention subsidy is a system in which the government provides partial wage subsidies to employers who must inevitably adjust employment due to decreased sales or downsizing, but choose to implement employment retention measures such as temporary closures or unpaid leave instead of laying off workers. Employers can retain skilled workers even in tough business conditions, and workers can avoid job loss, making this a representative employment safety net. The subsidy is provided in a way that partially reimburses the costs of temporary closure or unpaid leave allowances paid by the employer. This year, up to KRW 68,100 per day per worker is supported, for up to 180 days per year.
The Ministry of Employment and Labor explained that the reason for the reduced duration and amount per recipient is that the budget was estimated based on execution results over the past two to three years. The average subsidy reflected in the budget is not a future payment standard, but an estimate based on past execution data. An official from the Ministry stated, "The budget for employment retention subsidies is not artificially adjusted, but is set by multiplying the actual number of beneficiaries, the average duration, and the average benefit amount calculated from execution data."
It is noteworthy that as the average support period and amount have decreased in recent budget formulas, there are signs of changes in the actual structure of benefit receipt. While more companies and workers are now eligible compared to the past, the duration of temporary closures or unpaid leave at individual workplaces is getting shorter. The background to this is said to be changes in the pattern of industrial crises. During the COVID-19 period, industries such as airlines and tourism experienced prolonged business suspensions and closures. Recently, however, various external shocks—including U.S. tariff policies, rising oil prices due to instability in the Middle East, and surging raw material costs—have been impacting multiple sectors simultaneously. As more companies respond by adjusting production volumes or implementing short-term closures, there has been an increase in cases where subsidies are used for relatively short periods.
The government's move this year to ease the eligibility requirements for employment retention subsidies in the air transportation industry and the rubber and plastics manufacturing industries is also in line with this trend. The scope of the policy is expanding to address short-term management difficulties occurring across various sectors, rather than focusing on prolonged downturns in specific industries.
Steel products piled up at Pyeongtaek Port, Gyeonggi Province on March 12. Photo by Yonhap News
View original imageHowever, the broadening of support demand is not always seen as a positive development. The original purpose of the employment retention subsidy is to serve as a safety net that encourages companies facing temporary management crises to choose employment retention over layoffs. There are concerns, however, that as the scope of eligibility continues to widen, the program is solidifying into a permanent support policy instead of a temporary crisis response tool. In particular, if the practice of increasing the number of beneficiaries within the same budget continues, the impact of the support on individual workplaces may be diluted, leading to diminished policy effectiveness.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Additionally, if the actual number of eligible recipients exceeds the government's projections, it may become inevitable to adjust the budgets of other programs to secure additional resources, thereby increasing uncertainty in fund management. Since the employment retention subsidy is a statutory benefit, if demand exceeds the allocated budget, additional funds must be secured through procedures such as reallocating or transferring budgets from other projects within the employment insurance fund. Junmo Yang, professor of economics at Yonsei University, stated, "Fiscal spending must have a clear purpose and effect and should be operated temporarily, but since COVID-19, the employment retention subsidy has essentially become a permanent policy. The pool of beneficiaries will inevitably be limited, and expanding the number of recipients within the same budget, as seen this time, can reduce the effectiveness. Ultimately, this leads to 'fragmented support,' making the policy virtually meaningless."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.