Board Agenda Approval Rate at Major Corporations Remains Above 99%

Skepticism Over Outside Directors Persists Despite Institutional Changes

Substantive Role of Outside Directors Must Expand in a Changing Corporate Environment

[Reporter’s Notebook] Losing Reappointment for a Single Dissenting Vote: Boards Governed by Silence View original image

"Now is not the appropriate time to talk about the company."


Recently, while reporting on the outside director system, I requested interviews with dozens of outside directors. However, most declined for various reasons. Some said their research schedules were too busy, while others said the timing was not right. I also heard that it was difficult for them to speak up because their position as outside directors does not fully belong to either inside or outside the company. Although the wording differed, there was a common sentiment running through their responses: a sense of caution, stemming from the fear that saying something unnecessary might lead to disadvantages from the company.


Since the inauguration of the Lee Jaemyung administration, there has been a growing movement to strengthen the independence of outside directors. The term 'outside director' is being changed to 'independent director,' and on the surface, many changes are taking place, such as company heads stepping down from the position of board chair. However, the atmosphere on the ground was different. Boardrooms at Korea's major companies were still dominated by management. This is evident from the fact that the approval rate for board agenda items remains in the 99% range. An anonymous source shared a case where an outside director who voted against a major agenda item at a large company was not reappointed the following year. Although outside directors are expected to make independent judgments, the structure makes it difficult for them to voice independent opinions.


Outside directors are tasked with monitoring the company from a perspective independent of management and controlling shareholders. Since critical information and decision-making authority are concentrated with management, outside directors serve as a final safeguard to ensure that decisions are in the best interests of the company and all shareholders. Once reckless investments, corporate mergers, or conflict-of-interest transactions are decided, they can lead to the destruction of corporate value. This is why the role of the board is so important.


Even in the United States, where capitalism is firmly established, boards did not initially secure independence. Until the 1990s, many U.S. boards functioned merely as bodies that rubber-stamped management’s proposals after the fact. However, a series of major accounting scandals led to growing calls for greater accountability and independence for boards of directors.


In Korea as well, the era when the controlling family’s judgment automatically became the company’s decision is fading. Now, there is a stronger expectation to explain the legitimacy of decisions to the board, shareholders, and the market. What is needed is a firm commitment from companies to establish structures that allow outside directors to effectively check management. Mechanisms must be in place to guarantee outside directors the authority to review key decisions from the earliest stages, and to prevent management and controlling shareholders from wielding excessive influence during the appointment and reappointment process. In addition, directors should be given both the responsibility and the duty to understand information within the company and to speak candidly when needed.



Simply rebranding outside directors as 'independent directors' does not automatically make the board independent. What matters is not how many outsiders are seated on the board, but rather how free they are from conflicts of interest with the company, and how independently they can judge and speak up in front of management and controlling shareholders. In a boardroom where outside directors remain silent, neither effective checks on management nor proper protection of shareholder interests can be expected.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing