Son Taehwa, Chair of the Changwon Special City Council in Gyeongnam, has called for the city of Changwon to release the audit results for the “Big Tree” artificial structure project in Daesang Park, which has been embroiled in controversy as an “eyesore” due to its appearance being completely different from the original design renderings.


On June 16, at a press conference held at the city hall press center, Chair Son stated, “Last May, Changwon City completed its own investigation into the Big Tree project at Daesang Park, but has yet to report the audit results to the council,” expressing his deep regret over the matter.


He further criticized, “The Big Tree project, which reportedly cost 34.4 billion won, has sparked controversy not only locally but nationwide since July last year. In particular, there have been repeated criticisms of the unsightly exterior, and the sculptures have failed to gain public support from citizens.”


He added, “Through the legislative activities of Changwon city council members, various problems have been uncovered in the review process and design changes, and there have also been calls for audits to verify the actual project costs.”


Son Taehwa, Chairman of the Changwon Special City Council in Gyeongnam, is holding up a bird's-eye view and photos showing exterior changes of the Big Tree project at Daesanggong Park in Seongsan-gu, Changwon City during a press conference urging the city to disclose the audit results of the Big Tree project. <br/>Photo by Lee Seryeong

Son Taehwa, Chairman of the Changwon Special City Council in Gyeongnam, is holding up a bird's-eye view and photos showing exterior changes of the Big Tree project at Daesanggong Park in Seongsan-gu, Changwon City during a press conference urging the city to disclose the audit results of the Big Tree project.
Photo by Lee Seryeong

View original image

He said, “Changwon City is refusing to disclose the audit results on the grounds that reporting them to the council would make them public to citizens. This raises suspicions about the objectivity and reliability of the audit, suggesting it may have been incomplete, or that it is an attempt to cover up corruption or wrongdoing, if the audit results of a public project cannot be disclosed to citizens.”


He especially emphasized, “The council is an institution entrusted by citizens with the authority to oversee and monitor the executive branch. Refusing to disclose information to the council is tantamount to disregarding the citizens’ right to know and paralyzing the council’s legitimate oversight function.”


Chair Son demanded, “The city must immediately release the audit results to both the council and the citizens, and provide a responsible explanation for the various suspicions. Acting Mayor Jang Geumyong should directly announce the audit results related to the Big Tree to the public.”


He also added, “When the Big Tree was initially designed based on the winning entry from the public competition, it could have become an international landmark. However, the current Big Tree, far from referencing Singapore’s Super Tree, has instead become an international laughingstock. To make the Big Tree a world-class landmark, it should be rebuilt through a new design competition.”


Aerial view of the Big Tree sculpture at Daesang Park in Seongsan-gu, Changwon-si, Gyeongnam (above) and the installed Big Tree. [Photo by Changwon City and Changwon City Council]

Aerial view of the Big Tree sculpture at Daesang Park in Seongsan-gu, Changwon-si, Gyeongnam (above) and the installed Big Tree. [Photo by Changwon City and Changwon City Council]

View original image

The Big Tree, which was promoted as the symbolic structure of the Daesang Park private park development special project, was planned to be a large artificial tree and branch-shaped structure, 20 meters high, inspired by the Super Tree at Singapore’s Gardens by the Bay.


Originally, it was to be built as a 60-meter-tall structure with an artificial pine tree and observatory on the upper part, and a meditation center and media facade on the lower part. However, after construction began, safety concerns were raised regarding vulnerability to natural disasters, leading to design changes, and the 20-meter artificial tree on the upper part was not installed.


As a result, when the Big Tree was erected looking nothing like the initial rendering of a lush giant tree, citizens expressed disappointment. This led to media reports, audit requests by the city council, press conferences, and the “eyesore” controversy erupted.


In response, from February to May, Changwon City conducted a special audit to review the implementation of procedures and the appropriateness of administrative decisions related to the Big Tree installation.


The audit found that, during the process of changing the Big Tree’s design, the supervisors and private contractors failed to thoroughly check and review whether official procedures and reporting requirements under the relevant laws were properly followed. As a result, four out of the five responsible public officials received warnings or cautions, and disciplinary action was requested for one official.


Additionally, as the settlement procedures for the project expenses submitted by the private contractor are still ongoing, a final determination on the appropriateness of the total project cost cannot be made yet. However, the audit noted the possibility that unnecessary costs may have been included in the construction budget at the design stage of the Big Tree, and the city has requested a police investigation into the private contractor and related parties.


However, the city has decided not to disclose the details of the audit report.


The auditor explained, “There are obligations of confidentiality under the Local Public Officials Act, confidentiality clauses in agreements with the private contractor, and provisions in the Public Institutions Information Disclosure Act that restrict disclosure. As the project was based on such agreements, the city cannot provide the information without the other party’s consent.”



The auditor also added, “Since the audit results include matters referred for investigation and issues that could affect future disputes or lawsuits, disclosing the results could hinder the progress of investigations or legal proceedings.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing