Court Says "KFTC's Grounds for Changing Coupang's De Facto Owner Are Unconvincing"

At a court hearing to determine whether to suspend the effect of the Korea Fair Trade Commission's (KFTC) decision to designate Kim Beom-seok, Chairman of Coupang Inc., as the "de facto owner" (controlling shareholder), Coupang argued that the KFTC had reversed its previous decision without any special circumstances.

Kim Beomseok, Chairman of Coupang Inc. Photo by Yonhap News

Kim Beomseok, Chairman of Coupang Inc. Photo by Yonhap News

View original image

On June 16, the Seoul High Court's Administrative Division 7 (Presiding Judge Kwon Soon-hyung) held a hearing on Coupang's application to suspend the effect of the KFTC's change in the designation of the de facto owner. A suspension of execution is a procedure that temporarily halts the effect of an administrative disposition until a final verdict is reached in the main lawsuit.


During the hearing, Coupang emphasized that while the KFTC had designated the Coupang corporate entity as the de facto owner for about five years since 2021, it changed the designation to Kim Beom-seok, an individual, this April without any change in circumstances. Coupang stated, "Coupang is a typical foreign-based corporate group and its structure is different from domestic conglomerates," adding, "There was no substantial change in assessment criteria over the past five years that would warrant overturning the previous decision."


Coupang also argued that maintaining the change in the de facto owner designation would result in irreparable damage. As a U.S.-listed company, Coupang could face class-action lawsuits from investors if information is disclosed that exceeds the disclosure requirements of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).


The KFTC, however, stated that grounds for changing the de facto owner designation were identified during this year’s on-site audit. The Commission claimed that it was a legitimate decision because it was confirmed that Kim Beom-seok’s younger brother, Kim Yoo-seok, had in fact participated in the management of Coupang.


The KFTC explained, "Until last year, it was difficult to view Kim Yoo-seok as being involved in management, so the corporate entity was designated as the de facto owner. However, this year’s on-site audit confirmed Kim Yoo-seok’s participation in management, which provided grounds for changing the designation." As the basis for determining Kim Yoo-seok’s involvement, the KFTC cited his executive-level position, participation in decision-making processes, and influence over work.


Regarding Coupang's claim that excessive obligations are being imposed on foreign-based companies, the KFTC countered, "It is only natural for a company to comply with local laws when entering overseas markets," adding, "We cannot accept the argument that 'because it is a foreign-based company, the rules should not apply.'"


The court stated that it would reach a conclusion by July 15, the deadline for the provisional suspension set ex officio. The court also said, "The basis for changing the designation after the on-site audit is not convincing," and requested the KFTC to clearly organize the grounds for reaching a different conclusion regarding Kim Yoo-seok.



Previously, on April 29, the KFTC announced that it had changed the de facto owner designation to Chairman Kim after confirming that Kim Yoo-seok was in fact participating in Coupang's management. In response, on May 8, Coupang filed an administrative lawsuit and an application for suspension of execution seeking to reverse the decision.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing