Nonghyup Reform Task Force: "Audit Committee Independence Is Non-Negotiable... Corruption Stems from the Failure of the Current System"
Press Conference by the Nonghyup Reform Promotion Group on June 15
Promotion Group Refutes Nonghyup's Objections Point by Point, Reaffirms Commitment to Reform Plan
Second-Phase Reform Plan to Be Announced in July or August Following Enactment of First-Phase Bill in June
"The independence of the Nonghyup Audit Committee is not a matter for compromise or negotiation. This is the unified position of both the Promotion Group and the government." (Jang Kyungho, Secretary of the Economic Business Revitalization Subcommittee)
On June 15, the Public-Private Nonghyup Reform Promotion Group held a press conference at the government complex in Sejong, reiterating its commitment to the independence of the Nonghyup Audit Committee—specifically, the establishment of an external audit committee, a proposal which Nonghyup has effectively rejected. The Promotion Group argued that various irregularities and corruption within Nonghyup, as revealed by audits, stem from a weak internal audit system, thereby stressing the necessity for an external audit committee. The group also systematically refuted Nonghyup's objections to the reform plan and made clear its determination to push forward with the legislation of the first-phase reform bill without delay.
Won Seung-yeon, head of the Public-Private Nonghyup Reform Promotion Group (third from left), emphasized the necessity of Nonghyup reform at a press briefing held at the Government Complex Sejong on the 15th. Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs
View original imageJang Kyungho, Secretary of the Economic Business Revitalization Subcommittee, pointed out, "Nonghyup has repeatedly excused corruption and mismanagement as mere customs or practices, so even when these issues are detected, the penalties are too lenient, allowing internal problems to fester." He further criticized, "As long as the internal audit body remains unchanged, it is impossible to properly monitor the irregularities and corruption that have come to light within Nonghyup."
Earlier, in two announcements in March and April this year, the ruling party and the government unveiled plans for Nonghyup reform centered on establishing a new Audit Committee to make internal and union audits independent from the main association. Another core measure was to change the election method for the president of Nonghyup Central Association, so that all 1.87 million union members, rather than just 1,100 union heads, would have voting rights.
Since then, Nonghyup has maintained its opposition to both measures, claiming infringement of autonomy. However, on May 20—shortly after President Lee Jaemyung mentioned the need for reform—Chairman Kang Hodong announced via a statement that he would actively accept the direct election of union members. Nonetheless, regarding the establishment of an external audit committee, he made it clear that Nonghyup would not accept it, citing concerns about undermining overall management autonomy and stability.
On this point, Won Seungyeon, Co-Chair of the Promotion Group, remarked, "Nonghyup should indeed be an autonomous organization, but because this has not been properly realized for various reasons, public oversight is necessary." He added, "For autonomy to be ensured, accountability is fundamental. Refusing to be accountable goes against the current of society."
On that day, the Promotion Group systematically countered Nonghyup’s objections to the reform plan. Regarding the establishment of the external audit committee, Nonghyup argued that the right to audit unions is an exclusive authority of the Central Association, and raised concerns about excessive costs, estimating them at between 140 billion and 150 billion won. In response, Yoon Wonsup, Director of Agricultural Policy at the Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs, stated, "The right to audit unions is not the exclusive authority of the Central Association, but a matter of legislative discretion. The legislature determines the details by law, taking into account policy objectives and social conditions." He further explained, "The system will be designed so that costs can be managed at around 50 billion won—based on the current combined size of the union audit committee and internal audit committee, which is about 250 people."
The Promotion Group also refuted Nonghyup’s claim that introducing direct elections for union members would result in excessive election costs, describing this as an "overestimate." Furthermore, the group drew a firm line at Nonghyup’s demand that the government should cover these costs. Nonghyup has estimated that the implementation of direct presidential elections would incur a total of 40.6 billion won: 31.88 billion won for election commission fees and 8.74 billion won for campaign expenses. However, the Promotion Group explained that if the per-person commission fee for presidential elections (6,800 won) is applied, the cost would be approximately 17–19 billion won, and if the campaign spending limit for provincial governors under the Public Official Election Act is applied, campaign expenses would be 3.8 billion won—totaling about 20.8–22.8 billion won.
Director Yoon stated, "In reality, it is impossible to align the schedule for the local union head elections set for March 2027 and the Central Association presidential election set for March 2028, so there will be some cost increases. However, if both elections are held simultaneously in March 2031, the increase in costs will not be significant." He added, "As for the request for government compensation of expenses, it is fundamentally reasonable for Nonghyup to bear the costs, since under the Commissioned Election Act, Nonghyup is the commissioning party and these elections are for selecting its own representatives."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
The Promotion Group plans to review reform tasks and promote public discussion (such as forums) with the goal of announcing the reform plan in July or August after the enactment of the first-phase reform bill. Following the formation of the new National Assembly in the second half of the 22nd session this month, the group aims to push for the amendment of the Nonghyup Act containing the first-phase reform bill during the upcoming extraordinary session. By August at the latest, the group intends to announce a second-phase reform plan, which will include measures to revitalize economic projects through regional organization and expansion of sales organizations, as well as steps to strengthen the soundness of unions.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.