Pregnant Woman Suffers Miscarriage After Three Overnight Police Interrogations... Human Rights Commission: "Unlawful Infringement of Personal Liberty"
Miscarriage Confirmed the Day After Final Overnight Interrogation
Human Rights Commission Recognizes "Violation of Investigative Guidelines and Due Process"
Motion to Replace Investigator Dismissed... Damages Lawsuit Filed
The National Human Rights Commission of Korea (hereinafter referred to as "the Commission") has acknowledged violations of investigative guidelines and due process in a case where a woman in her 30s miscarried after undergoing three separate late-night interrogations by the police, each lasting more than 12 hours. As a result, the Commission has issued recommendation decisions to the Commissioner General of the Korean National Police Agency and the Commissioner of the Seoul Metropolitan Police Agency.
According to legal sources on June 16, the Commission ruled on May 26 in a complaint filed by Ms. A (female) against Inspector B (female) and Senior Inspector C of the Financial Crime Investigation Unit at the Seoul Metropolitan Police Agency. The complaint alleged "fetal death due to coercive police investigation, among other issues." The Commission found that "the investigation violated the guidelines and the constitutional principle of due process, thereby infringing upon the complainant's physical liberty."
Seoul Metropolitan Police Agency building, Jongno-gu, Seoul. Photo by Yonhap News
View original imageThe Commission first recommended that the Commissioner General of the Korean National Police Agency take measures to prevent late-night interrogations from becoming routine. Specifically, the Commission advised that late-night interrogation request forms should include concrete reasons why reappearance is difficult and provide substantial grounds for the request. Furthermore, in determining whether to permit late-night or prolonged interrogations, investigators should be required to record if a suspect or related party informs them of pregnancy, serious illness, advanced age, disability, or other physical or mental health conditions.
Additionally, the Commission recommended three measures to the Commissioner of the Seoul Metropolitan Police Agency: ▲ issue a warning to Inspector B for directly conducting excessive late-night interrogations; ▲ conduct job training for all investigators at the Seoul Metropolitan Police Agency, including Inspector B, regarding the principle of restricting late-night and prolonged interrogations; and ▲ review whether there is a practice of late-night interrogations being conducted based on perfunctorily completed request forms.
Last year, Ms. A, in her role as promoter for the Asian tour of a renowned European professional soccer team, became involved in a civil lawsuit and a criminal complaint due to conflicts with Genesis BBQ Co., Ltd., the main sponsor of the Seoul match.
Inspector B questioned Ms. A on three occasions: December 30 and 31 of last year, and January 22 of this year. Although Ms. A informed Inspector B of her pregnancy, all three interrogations were conducted from morning until nearly midnight.
The first interrogation lasted a total of 13 hours and 34 minutes, from 9:40 a.m. to 11:13 p.m. Excluding breaks and 36 minutes spent reviewing the written record, the actual interrogation time amounted to 9 hours and 59 minutes. The second and third sessions also spanned long periods, with total interrogation times of 12 hours and 35 minutes (actual interrogation time: 8 hours and 40 minutes) and 13 hours and 50 minutes (actual interrogation time: 10 hours and 40 minutes), respectively.
During the final interrogation on January 22, Ms. A underwent an intensive late-night session, including a confrontation investigation. On her way home in the early morning of January 23, she experienced abdominal pain, and the following day, she was diagnosed with a miscarriage and underwent a uterine evacuation procedure at the hospital. Ms. A's side asserts that the nearly 14-hour interrogation conducted by the police had some impact on the miscarriage, especially since the fetus had been confirmed healthy on an ultrasound just eight days earlier, on January 14.
The Commission also stated, "Article 23 of the Investigation Guidelines requires investigators to grant suspects a break of at least 10 minutes every two hours unless there are special circumstances. However, in this case, it was confirmed in the records that each of the three interrogations lasted over two hours without breaks." The Commission continued, "Although we cannot determine a medical causal relationship between the miscarriage and the interrogations, Inspector B repeatedly violated the legal principles restricting late-night and prolonged interrogations despite being aware of the complainant's pregnancy, and failed to provide adequate protections. Considering these procedural violations, Inspector B's actions can be seen as infringing upon the complainant's physical liberty in violation of the principle of due process."
Article 21 of the 'Regulations on Mutual Cooperation between Prosecutors and Judicial Police Officers and General Investigative Guidelines' (Investigation Guidelines) generally prohibits late-night interrogations between 9 p.m. and 6 a.m. Exceptions are extremely limited and include situations such as investigations for requesting or applying for an arrest warrant for a detained suspect, cases where the statute of limitations is imminent, or when a suspect requests a late-night interrogation due to concrete reasons such as impending travel abroad making reappearance difficult. Article 22 of the guidelines also stipulates that total interrogation time should not exceed 12 hours and actual interrogation time should not exceed 8 hours.
The Commission acknowledged that Inspector B violated these restrictions on late-night and prolonged interrogations as set forth in the guidelines. Furthermore, although late-night interrogation request forms were submitted for two of the three interrogations, the Commission found that these requests were primarily made due to the investigative agency's need to proceed with the investigation, rather than at the complainant's initiative due to difficulty in reappearing.
The Commission also addressed Inspector B's argument that "when a suspect submits a late-night interrogation request form, late-night interrogations are conducted without assessing the specific reasons, and in practice, it is customary for interrogations to exceed two hours." The Commission stated, "Such practices do not align with the intent of Article 195 of the Criminal Procedure Act and the Investigation Guidelines, which were established to eradicate coercive investigative practices and prevent human rights violations such as false confessions."
Finally, the Commission emphasized, "Given that the investigators were aware of the complainant's pregnancy, they should have taken protective measures, such as dividing the investigation schedule, rather than forcing the investigation to proceed solely due to the volume of material to be covered."
The Commission added, "In this case, total interrogation time exceeded 12 hours on both December 30 and 31, 2025, and on January 22, 2026, the actual interrogation time, including the confrontation investigation, reached 10 hours and 40 minutes. In light of these circumstances, it is difficult to conclude that Inspector B took adequate protective measures for the pregnant complainant."
After confirming her miscarriage, Ms. A filed a motion to have the investigating officer replaced, citing Inspector B's biased investigative attitude and other reasons. However, Senior Inspector C, Ms. A's supervisor, submitted a written opinion stating that the grounds did not warrant replacement, and the motion was ultimately dismissed.
Ms. A recently filed a lawsuit at the Seoul Central District Court seeking damages from Inspector B, Senior Inspector C, and others.
Attorney Park Jinsik of the law firm Between, representing Ms. A, stated, "The investigation was so harshly in violation of human rights that it resulted in a miscarriage, yet the police neither responded to Ms. A's certified mail requesting an apology and explanation, nor did they ever apologize. Given that the Commission has also recognized that the miscarriage resulted from harsh investigations without sufficient rest or guaranteed breaks, we will do our utmost to have the court recognize the causal link of the unlawful act."
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
A Seoul Metropolitan Police Agency official commented, "We regret the miscarriage and respect the Commission's decision, and we will diligently implement the recommended measures." The official added, "However, the claims regarding coercive investigation are disputed between both parties, and as the causal relationship with the miscarriage is not clear, we believe it is unreasonable to directly link the police investigation to the miscarriage."
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.