[Economy Pulse] The Light and Shadow of the 500 Trillion Won ETF Era View original image

The total net asset value of Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) has surpassed 500 trillion won, approaching the total market capitalization of KOSDAQ. The number of ETF listings has also reached around 1,000. With the recent spotlight on newly launched single-stock leveraged products, public interest in ETFs is rising.


An ETF is a product designed to hedge risks through diversified investment. A typical ETF is required to hold at least 10 different stocks, with a maximum allocation of 30% to any single stock. ETFs come in a variety of forms—not only tracking market indices but also focusing on sectors, themes, and offering leverage and inverse products. Recently, revisions to the Enforcement Decree of the Capital Markets Act and the Financial Investment Business Regulation have allowed the creation of leveraged and inverse products composed solely of a single stock.


ETFs have been amplifying the gains of stock market indices. This is because Samsung Electronics and SK hynix, both hitting record highs due to the semiconductor boom, are major constituents in a wide range of ETFs. Each of these two stocks is included in about 400 different ETFs. When investors buy an ETF that includes these two stocks, the securities firms managing the ETF must purchase the underlying shares, which in turn fuels further rises in the stock prices.


The widespread adoption of ETFs is also contributing to the development of the capital market. The shift of funds from real estate or savings to equities is positive in terms of capital efficiency and investment returns. In particular, ETFs have become a core product for retirement pensions, including Individual Retirement Pensions (IRP). At the end of last year, the balance of ETF investments in retirement pension accounts reached 50 trillion won, with a growth rate of 100%. This marks the full-fledged advent of the era of indirect investment. For domestic investors, who tend to have a higher proportion of direct investment compared to global peers, ETFs can help improve risk-adjusted returns.


However, there are significant downsides. One of the main criticisms is that ETFs can increase market volatility. Traditionally, ETF trading is influenced by the underlying stocks included in the fund. However, the recently introduced single-stock leveraged products have reversed this cause-and-effect relationship, leading to the so-called "tail wagging the dog" phenomenon. When investors buy leveraged ETFs, liquidity providers (LPs) or authorized participants (APs) may purchase both spot and futures contracts (spot-type) or only futures contracts (futures-type). Excessive buying of futures drives up futures prices, and arbitrage traders profit by selling futures and buying spot shares. This in turn leads to a rise in spot prices, further boosting the prices of the underlying stocks. The opposite occurs in the case of selling. Especially when expiring futures contracts are not rolled over to the next month by LPs, APs, or arbitrage traders and are instead liquidated, the price impact is amplified. One of the reasons for the sharp drop in the index ahead of last week's futures expiration can be found here. Of course, global events—such as the SpaceX IPO or the likelihood of U.S. interest rate hikes—were the main causes of the price decline, but leveraged products also had a considerable impact on the futures market during the downturn.


The concentration of ETFs on specific stocks can also lead to polarization in the equity market. The difference in price appreciation between stocks included in ETFs and those excluded can be significant. Small- and mid-cap stocks, as well as neglected stocks, inevitably suffer. Even if included in an ETF, stocks with low weighting can be force-sold if the ETF price falls due to a decline in the price of heavily weighted constituent stocks. Furthermore, if stock prices are determined by whether or not they are included in ETFs rather than by their intrinsic corporate value, the price discovery function is weakened. If companies with a high ETF inclusion ratio can more easily raise capital, this could also result in distortions in capital allocation.


In order to promote market growth, index appreciation, and a culture of indirect investment, the ETF market needs to continue expanding. However, ETFs that excessively amplify volatility, operate in environments lacking sufficient hedging infrastructure such as the futures market, or encourage speculative day trading through record-high turnover rates should be avoided. In the U.S., ETFs tracking the S&P 500 Index serve as de facto national funds. It is hoped that the ETF market in Korea will develop soundly through attractive indices and innovative product development.



Junseo Lee, Professor of Business Administration at Dongguk University


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing