Win-Win Union Faces Internal Discord Over Push for Independence
Criticism Mounts Over "Excessive Financial Authority Granted to Executive Leadership"

As the Samsung BioLogics Win-Win Labor Union (hereafter, Win-Win Union) moves to withdraw from an industry-level union and transition to an independent union, significant internal backlash is mounting over a proposed amendment to the union bylaws. The amendment includes a provision that concentrates key decision-making authority regarding union finances—such as living expense support and the operation of struggle funds—in the hands of the Executive Committee, rather than the delegates’ council or a general assembly of union members. This has raised concerns that the system of checks and balances on the executive leadership could be weakened.


According to industry sources on June 12, the leadership of the Win-Win Union recently notified members that a general assembly will be held over a three-day period from June 16 to 18. The main agenda of this general assembly is the withdrawal from the industry-level union and the establishment of an independent union. However, some union members are raising concerns that the proposed bylaw amendment, which has been introduced alongside the withdrawal agenda, excessively centralizes financial management authority in the hands of the executive leadership.


Samsung BioLogics Plant 4 in Songdo, Incheon. Samsung BioLogics

Samsung BioLogics Plant 4 in Songdo, Incheon. Samsung BioLogics

View original image

The most contentious issue is the clause concerning "living expense support." The proposed amendment from the Win-Win Union’s leadership stipulates that both the scope and specific procedures for living expense support can be determined solely by the resolution of the Executive Committee (i.e., the union’s officers).


Typically, unions require important financial decisions—such as the allocation of union dues or the establishment of funds—to be reviewed by a delegates’ council or to undergo a process of gathering input from all union members, as a basic safeguard against improper expenditures or biased administration. This is because the union’s finances are directly tied to the interests of all its members. If the new amendment is approved, however, the criteria and procedures for living expense support could be set exclusively by the Executive Committee, making it difficult to maintain oversight of the executive leadership’s financial management. This has prompted criticism that the amendment is less about benefiting union members and more about preemptively enabling discretionary financial control by the leadership.


The amendment also introduces a new provision on “struggle fund accumulation and emergency financial measures” in Article 28 (Accounting), designating the establishment and management of such funds as matters to be decided solely by the Executive Committee. Since emergency financial measures and the creation of large-scale funds are directly linked to members’ interests, allowing these decisions to be made solely at the discretion of the officers has drawn criticism that the union’s finances could end up being managed as opaque discretionary funds by the leadership.



Within the Win-Win Union, there has been a wave of criticism that the executive leadership is using the banner of “independent union formation” to obscure the real intent of monopolizing authority at the expense of members’ oversight. One Samsung BioLogics employee posted on the company’s Blind community, saying, “Looking at Article 21 (Protection of Officers’ Status) of the bylaw amendment released on the website, it’s unclear why living expense support was included. Given the current financial status, there is a significant risk that the criteria for living expense payments could be determined arbitrarily by the Executive Committee. Critical issues like this should not be decided unilaterally by the leadership but must be settled with input from all union members.”


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing