KFTC Sends Review Report to Korea Zinc
Calls for Sanctions over 'Prohibition of Evasive Acts' under Fair Trade Act
If Found Illegal, Governance Risk to Escalate... Justifying Young Poong’s Offensive

The Korea Fair Trade Commission (KFTC) has tentatively concluded that Korea Zinc's core management rights defense tactic, the "cross-shareholding card," constitutes an illegal act and has initiated formal sanction procedures. There is now a possibility that the long-running management rights dispute—nearly two years in the making—between the alliance of Young Poong and MBK Partners and Yoonbeom Choi, Chairman of Korea Zinc, may reach a turning point.

Yoonbeom Choi, Chairman of Korea Zinc, spoke as a speaker at the Korea-Canada Energy Resource Supply Chain Cooperation Forum held on the 10th. The Asia Business Daily DB.

Yoonbeom Choi, Chairman of Korea Zinc, spoke as a speaker at the Korea-Canada Energy Resource Supply Chain Cooperation Forum held on the 10th. The Asia Business Daily DB.

View original image

According to industry sources on June 12, the KFTC sent a review report (equivalent to an indictment by prosecutors) to Korea Zinc in April. The KFTC investigator looked into Korea Zinc's acquisition of Young Poong shares via its Australian subsidiary Sun Metals Holdings (SMH) and its sub-subsidiary Sun Metals Corporation (SMC), which resulted in a circular shareholding structure—"Korea Zinc → SMH → SMC → Young Poong → Korea Zinc." The KFTC reportedly judged this as an "evasion act" intended to circumvent domestic regulations on reciprocal shareholding restrictions. After gathering Korea Zinc’s opinions over an eight-week period, the KFTC is expected to convene a plenary session as early as August to finalize its decision.

Courts Focused on ‘Procedural Legitimacy’…KFTC Targets ‘Intent to Distort Governance Structure’

This sanction process began in January last year, when the Young Poong-MBK Partners alliance reported a possible Fair Trade Act violation to the KFTC. The KFTC's direction contrasts with the conclusions previously reached by the judiciary. In April, the Supreme Court ultimately dismissed an appeal filed by the Young Poong-MBK alliance seeking to suspend the resolution of a regular general shareholders' meeting. The court ruled that restricting Young Poong's voting rights at the meeting, based on the cross-shareholding relationship, fulfilled "procedural legality" within the framework of commercial law.


In contrast, the KFTC applied Article 36 of the Fair Trade Act (Prohibition of Evasion Acts), independent of whether procedures required by commercial law were followed. The "cross-shareholding strategy" played a decisive role for Chairman Choi's side in defending management rights during the early stages of the dispute. By exploiting the commercial law provision that voting rights are restricted in the case of cross-shareholding relationships, Chairman Choi's side essentially neutralized the voting rights of the largest shareholders—the Young Poong-MBK alliance—a day before an extraordinary shareholders' meeting in January last year. Although this cross-shareholding structure was later dissolved, under the cumulative voting system, Chairman Choi's side has maintained a 9-to-5 advantage on the board, defending management rights up to the present.

Will Foreign Investors Turn Away? ‘Governance Risk’ Tightens from All Sides

[Why&Next] KFTC Launches Sanction Process on Korea Zinc’s Circular Cross-Shareholding...Turning Point in Management Rights Dispute? View original image

With the KFTC now questioning the "purpose" and "illegality" of the structure, the management rights dispute has entered a new phase. Should the KFTC conclude in its upcoming plenary session that this was an evasion act, the scenario devised by the Young Poong-MBK alliance—gradually expanding the board to seize a majority—could accelerate.


For foreign institutional investors who prioritize transparent governance, as well as major shareholders holding the casting vote such as the National Pension Service, a "management team confirmed to have violated the law" would be a major risk factor. The National Pension Service sent a warning signal by voting against Chairman Choi’s agenda at the regular shareholders’ meeting in March. Since neither side holds a majority stake, the votes of general shareholders—amounting to nearly 20%—will likely determine the outcome of future shareholder meetings. On top of this, further legal and governance risks have emerged for Korea Zinc, with the Securities and Futures Commission recently confirming heavy sanctions (including the designation of an auditor and fines) for accounting standard violations, and minority shareholders filing a criminal complaint with the prosecution.



An investment banking (IB) source commented, "The cross-shareholding card was a decisive early advantage for Chairman Choi’s camp, but ultimately, the attempt to circumvent legal regulations has come back as a major boomerang. The KFTC’s final decision could serve as a catalyst for a war of public opinion among shareholders and reignite the MBK–Young Poong alliance’s all-out offensive."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing