Carlyle Also Steps Back... Back to Hillhouse Again
Ongoing Disagreement Over Price... Seller's Bargaining Power Weakens

Aegis Asset Management Sale Drags On... Ultimately, It's All About the Price View original image

The sale process for Aegis Asset Management has been slow to gain momentum. Negotiations with Hillhouse Investment, which was selected as the preferred bidder, have dragged on for an extended period. Meanwhile, the sellers also approached global private equity fund Carlyle Group as a potential buyer, but the deal ultimately did not materialize. While several variables have emerged—including disputes with the National Pension Service, controversy regarding Hillhouse's Chinese capital, and questions about the fairness of the bidding process—market consensus is that the core issue in this transaction is price.


Carlyle Withdraws... Prolonged Sale Battle

According to the investment banking (IB) industry on June 12, Carlyle recently reviewed the acquisition of Aegis Asset Management but ultimately decided not to proceed. Carlyle Asia considered using Aegis as a base for real estate and infrastructure investment in Asia, but it is understood that it was difficult to secure investment approval from its New York headquarters. Given that Hillhouse had previously valued Aegis at around 1.1 trillion won, any new bidder would have had to match this price, which appears to have been a major obstacle.


As recently as the end of last year, the sale of Aegis attracted significant market attention as a major asset management deal valued at over 1 trillion won. Hillhouse reportedly raised its acquisition offer to about 1.1 trillion won through additional competitive bidding after the main bid, and was selected as the preferred bidder based on this price. Heungkuk Life Insurance is reported to have offered 1.05 trillion won, and Hanwha Life Insurance 900 billion won.


However, the atmosphere changed after the preferred bidder was selected. The share purchase agreement (SPA) between Hillhouse and the sellers has been delayed for months. Key issues have included the risk of regulatory approval for a change of major shareholder and the handling of the deposit. In typical M&A transactions, the deposit is around 10% of the deal size, which in the case of Aegis could amount to over 100 billion won. From Hillhouse's perspective, there was concern about potentially losing the entire deposit if regulatory approval was not granted.


There are increasing doubts as to whether the 1.1 trillion won offer proposed by Hillhouse was ever a realistic price that could see the transaction through to completion. Some in the market interpret Hillhouse's bid as a "strategic price" aimed at securing preferred bidder status in the early stages of competition. After due diligence, factors such as disputes with the National Pension Service, the potential outflow of key managed assets, and the risk of major shareholder approval have made it difficult to accept the originally proposed price and conditions as they were. The conflict with the National Pension Service raised questions about whether Aegis's assets under management (AUM) and fee base could be maintained, while the controversy over Hillhouse's Chinese capital further heightened concerns over deal closure and deposit risk.

Aegis Asset Management Sale Drags On... Ultimately, It's All About the Price View original image

Stalemate Over Price... Seller's Bargaining Power Weakens

Industry observers say the sellers remain unwilling to drop the lower limit of the sale price below around 1 trillion won, resulting in a stalemate. Aegis has a complex web of stakeholders, including the founder's family and financial investors. Since Hillhouse once proposed a price of about 1.1 trillion won, it is not easy for the representatives of the shareholders to accept a much lower price.


Conflicts with Heungkuk Life Insurance have also made it difficult to lower the price. Heungkuk Life Insurance has filed a police complaint against the sale managers, including Morgan Stanley, the largest shareholder Hwa-Ja Son, and shareholder representative Ae-Mi Kim, arguing that the selection of Hillhouse as the preferred bidder was unfair. If the deal with Hillhouse is renegotiated at a lower price than initially agreed, the fairness of the previous bidding process could become a renewed issue. The sellers thus face a choice between lowering the price to complete the transaction and defending the legitimacy of the original bidding process.


The return of CEO Gap-Joo Cho is seen as an effort to stabilize the sale process. Cho, a key figure in the company's growth, is highly regarded for his understanding of the limited partner (LP) network and the internal organization. He is acting as a "firefighter," aiming to restore relations with major LPs such as the National Pension Service and to prevent the company from being destabilized by the prolonged sale process. Cho's return itself could be interpreted as a signal that the Aegis sale is unlikely to conclude quickly.



The problem is that potential buyers are well aware of the sellers' predicament. Although Hillhouse's position as preferred bidder has effectively weakened, there are no obvious alternatives. Global private equity funds such as Carlyle, which showed strategic interest, have also withdrawn due to price concerns, revealing that there are few buyers willing to pay over 1 trillion won. An industry insider commented, "This weakens the bargaining power of the sellers. While efforts to find a new buyer may continue, as long as the sellers insist on a price above 1 trillion won, the sale is likely to drag on for a long time."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing