Court: "No Ballot Paper Box Found at Polling Station"


"Verification to Be Rescheduled Once Location Identified"

'Ballot Paper Box' Missing... Court Says "Unable to Verify" View original image

The judiciary attempted a compulsory on-site inspection at the polling station where a ballot paper shortage sparked controversy during the June 3 local elections; however, the execution failed as a key piece of evidence had vanished without a trace. The National Election Commission (NEC) has maintained that it does not possess the missing item, raising the prospect of escalating disputes over responsibility for the whereabouts of the lost election evidence.


On the afternoon of June 10, Presiding Judge Kim Jiyeon of the 51st Civil Division, Seoul Eastern District Court, visited the senior center of Woosung Apartment in Jamsil 7-dong, which served as the second polling station, to secure evidence. However, the judge notified the press that no relevant materials were present, making a substantive investigation impossible. The court announced it would reschedule the inspection once the location of the box is identified through subsequent written investigations or other means.

Officials from the Seoul Eastern District Court are leaving after completing an on-site inspection at the elderly center in an apartment complex, which was the second polling station in Jamsil 7-dong, Songpa-gu, Seoul during the June 3 local elections on the 10th. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

Officials from the Seoul Eastern District Court are leaving after completing an on-site inspection at the elderly center in an apartment complex, which was the second polling station in Jamsil 7-dong, Songpa-gu, Seoul during the June 3 local elections on the 10th. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

The NEC has reportedly explained that the missing box was simply a transportation container for ballot papers, not a formal "ballot box," and thus there is no legal obligation to preserve it. Some have raised the possibility that after public authorities moved the ballot boxes on June 5, outsiders who entered the meeting hall may have removed the box during a search of the office equipment.


The lost box had been regarded as a crucial clue to proving the NEC's administrative negligence. According to photos taken at the scene, the outside of the box was marked "1,900 copies printed," which amounts to only 49.3% of the total number of eligible voters in the district (3,856 people). This falls short of the NEC's own internal guidelines, which require printing at least more than half the number of eligible voters in each district.


In addition to the ballot paper transport box, the court recognized as evidence to be preserved: three days' worth (from 8 a.m. on June 3 to 9 p.m. on June 5) of CCTV footage from the 10 polling stations in Songpa District where issues arose, as well as real-time mobile messenger and text message records exchanged among NEC officials during the incident. The judiciary has formally requested these materials to be submitted.



This legal procedure was initiated after Kim Jeongcheol, Supreme Council member of the Reform Party, filed a court petition on June 8 to prevent evidence from being lost prior to launching an election annulment lawsuit. As an observer with standing in the case, Supreme Council member Kim stated, "The key evidence that would have proven the NEC failed to meet even its own minimum standards has disappeared." He announced plans to formally file an election objection around June 15 and said he would consider requesting additional preservation of the ballot boxes stored at the counting center, depending on the response to the court's requests.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing