No Payment or Secondary Damages... Possible Grounds for Leniency?
Delayed and Underreported Disclosure Fueled Controversy
‘Up to 10% of Revenue’ Fine Not Applicable

A decision regarding Coupang, which caused a personal information leak affecting more than 33.67 million cases last November, may be made as early as June 10. As this was the largest data breach ever for a domestic company, there is keen interest in whether the penalty will also be unprecedented, and whether factors such as the fact that sensitive information like payment data was not leaked will be considered in determining the fine.


A view of a Coupang logistics center in Seoul city. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

A view of a Coupang logistics center in Seoul city. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

The Personal Information Protection Commission will hold a plenary meeting on this day to review the proposed disciplinary measures against Coupang concerning the personal information leak. Nearly seven months have passed since the incident occurred. In April, the commission sent Coupang a preliminary notice detailing the violations of the Personal Information Protection Act and the proposed sanctions, to which Coupang reportedly submitted an explanation. The commission has been preparing its review by examining Coupang’s response until recently.


According to the joint public-private investigation team’s findings announced by the Ministry of Science and ICT in February, the leaked personal information from Coupang included names, email addresses, and shipping address books, totaling 33,670,817 cases. This surpasses the April 2023 SK Telecom USIM information leak (23.24 million cases), making it the largest ever by a private company in Korea. Additionally, as shipping addresses and contact information of third parties such as family and friends registered by Coupang members were also compromised, it is estimated that the actual number of affected people may be much higher.


As a result, there are industry predictions that Coupang may face the largest fine ever imposed. The industry expects a fine two to three times greater than that imposed on SK Telecom.


Under the current Personal Information Protection Act, fines can be levied up to 3% of annual sales in the event of a data breach. Coupang reported revenue of 45.5 trillion won last year, which means that, if applied directly, the fine could amount to about 1.3637 trillion won. However, the actual fine may be lower, as it is determined by considering the revenue related to the violation and any mitigating or aggravating factors, so it may not reach the legal maximum. Even for SK Telecom, which previously received the largest fine, the penalty was set at around 134.8 billion won, or 1% of sales, as efforts to remedy the incident were taken into account.


Coupang has emphasized that no secondary damages have been identified and that sensitive information such as financial or payment data and USIM authentication keys were not leaked. The company also stated that it took active measures to retrieve personal information after the incident. The joint public-private investigation team also stated, "There was no evidence that the attacker transferred data externally, and there were no payment-related or secondary damages."


However, significant controversy arose from the fact that Coupang violated the government’s order to preserve records for investigating the leak’s route by deleting five months’ worth of web access logs and other records, and by underreporting the scale of the breach at the time of the initial incident report.


The Personal Information Protection Commission has indicated it will strictly apply mitigating and aggravating factors. Chairperson Song Kyung-hee said during a briefing last month, "We will ensure that any misconduct is met with appropriate sanctions according to the principles of the law."



Online video service TVING and CU convenience store parcel service, both of which have recently experienced personal information leaks, are closely watching the outcome of Coupang’s review. None of these cases are subject to the revised Personal Information Protection Act, which allows fines of up to 10% of annual sales, as the revision will take effect in September.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing