Established as a Constitutional Institution After the March 15 Fraudulent Election
Decentralized Authority Strengthened Political Independence
Part-Time Chairperson, Unclear Responsibility
Organization Expanded, but External Oversight Remai

"In order to secure fairness in elections, the Election Commission was established as a constitutional body." (May 1960, Jeong Heonju, Chairman of the Drafting Committee for the Cabinet System Amendment at the National Assembly)

The National Election Commission, which was established as a result of the March 15 fraudulent election and the April 19 Revolution, has stood as an independent constitutional body free from political power for over 60 years. However, while its independence has been strengthened, mechanisms for accountability and checks have remained insufficient.


On the 8th, participants shouted slogans in front of the entrance of the Handball Stadium at Olympic Park in Songpa-gu, Seoul, where the 'Jamsil Counting Center Blockade Protest' demanding a re-election in condemnation of the ballot paper shortage during the June 3 local elections was continuing. Photo by Yonhap News

On the 8th, participants shouted slogans in front of the entrance of the Handball Stadium at Olympic Park in Songpa-gu, Seoul, where the 'Jamsil Counting Center Blockade Protest' demanding a re-election in condemnation of the ballot paper shortage during the June 3 local elections was continuing. Photo by Yonhap News

View original image

Decentralized Election Commission... Responsibility Scattered as Well

The Election Commission became a constitutional body starting with the third amendment to the Constitution in 1960. At that time, the Constitution stipulated, "A Central Election Commission shall be established to ensure the fair management of elections." Under the First Republic, election management was, in practice, the responsibility of the government. For example, all nine members of the Central Election Commission were recommended by the Minister of Home Affairs and appointed by the President.


After the third constitutional amendment, the principle of dispersing power to strengthen the Commission's independence was maintained. Under the Constitution of the Second Republic, election commission members began as three Supreme Court Justices (elected among themselves) and six members recommended by political parties. Starting from the Fifth Republic, the system was established so that the President, Chief Justice, and National Assembly each appoint, elect, or nominate three members.


The problem is that responsibility has also become dispersed. By convention, the chairperson is a Supreme Court Justice, as they are considered less likely to become embroiled in political neutrality controversies, and the position has essentially become non-full-time. Currently, among the eight members, three are appointed by the President, two by the Chief Justice and opposition parties, and one by the ruling party, creating a structure where it is difficult for any one side to take full responsibility.


Expanded Role and Size, but Weak Oversight Mechanisms

Heo Cheolhun, Secretary-General of the National Election Commission, and officials are issuing a public apology at the Central Election Commission office in Gwacheon, Gyeonggi Province, on the 3rd, the main voting day of the June 3 local elections, regarding the shortage of ballots. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

Heo Cheolhun, Secretary-General of the National Election Commission, and officials are issuing a public apology at the Central Election Commission office in Gwacheon, Gyeonggi Province, on the 3rd, the main voting day of the June 3 local elections, regarding the shortage of ballots. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

The Election Commission's working-level organization was initially very small. The only regulation for the Central Election Commission stated, "There shall be one director and a few clerks." Over the past 60 years, as its responsibilities expanded to include political parties and political funds, it has become a large organization with over 3,000 members. The Secretary-General, who oversees the working-level organization and is of ministerial rank, has usually been appointed through the Commission's resolution from among internal officials.


The standing commissioner, who should provide oversight as a full-time position, does not have their authority and responsibility precisely defined. Of course, the National Assembly (through inspections and budget reviews), the Board of Audit and Inspection (audits of budget and accounting), the courts (election-related lawsuits), and prosecutors and police (investigations of criminal allegations) can all provide oversight, but their roles are limited. The National Assembly cannot discipline general employees, and the Board of Audit and Inspection does not have the authority to audit election-related affairs or duties.


Kim Seontaek, professor at Korea University Law School, commented, "As the joke goes, the problem with the Election Commission is that there is no one ultimately responsible." Woonsup Shin, professor at Kyungpook National University Law School, added, "While external controls were absent, the Secretary-General and other members of the Commission increasingly monopolized authority. In these circumstances, with the (non-full-time) Supreme Court Justice serving as chairperson and the Secretariat hiding behind, accountability has become blurred."



Editor's NoteThe National Election Commission, a constitutional body, is facing its greatest crisis in over 60 years since its establishment. This article examines the circumstances and issues surrounding the 'ballot paper shortage incident' during the ninth nationwide local elections, as well as potential measures for improvement going forward.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing