Gwangjang and Taepyeongyang Stirred... 'Partner Retirement Age at 65' Domino Hits Major Law Firms [Invest&Law]
Retirement Age Debate Shakes Major Law Firms
Should Partners Retire at 60 or 65?
Experience Matters for Profitability
But Challenging to Serve Younger Corporate Clients
Recently, a trend toward extending the retirement age for partners has been accelerating across major law firms. Following Hwawoo’s decision last month to extend its mandatory retirement age from 63 to 65, Gwangjang is also set to discuss the possibility of extending the retirement age to 65 at its general partners’ meeting scheduled for February next year. Rather than a top-down decision by management, Gwangjang has chosen to put the retirement age extension on the agenda for a vote by all partners. The intention is for management to remain neutral and let the partners decide for themselves.
According to the legal industry on June 10, among the top six major law firms, Kim & Chang does not have a uniform mandatory retirement age for partners, while Sejong, Yulchon, and Hwawoo set it at 65, and Gwangjang and Taepyungyang set it at 60. Taepyungyang recently considered a retirement age extension, but ultimately withdrew the proposal after discussions. Since law firms operate as partnership structures in which partners are co-owners, sensitive issues like the retirement age are difficult to decide without broad consensus. Lawyers note that the debate over extending the retirement age has exposed significant generational conflicts. This is because multiple issues are intertwined, including the distribution of limited profits, succession of key clients, and cost efficiency.
Retirement Age Means 'Equity Return,' Not 'Full Retirement'
At major law firms, the retirement age for partners does not mean complete withdrawal from work as it would for ordinary employees. In practice, it refers to the 'equity (dividend) retirement age,' which determines the right to profit distribution. Even after reaching the mandatory retirement age, partners may continue to work as advisors or on a contract basis, but since they must return their equity, they can no longer expect to receive profit distributions. There are also concerns that clients may perceive them as having stepped back from hands-on work, which could negatively impact business development activities.
For this reason, extending the retirement age at law firms can be interpreted as senior partners monopolizing core decision-making power and profit-sharing for an extended period. From the perspective of younger lawyers, a structure in which senior lawyers retain significant equity means a reduced share for themselves and delays in advancement to key positions. One partner lawyer at a law firm commented, "Younger lawyers feel that as the number of senior partners increases, their opportunities to inherit major corporate clients and grow become more limited, and there are concerns that extending the retirement age serves as a tool for the current management to prolong their hold on power."
Experience Matters, But Calls for Generational Change Persist
However, there is also a pragmatic view that extending the retirement age for senior partners is unavoidable from a profitability perspective. Retaining the solid client pool held by senior partners and allowing them to continue exerting influence is directly linked to stable revenue generation for the entire law firm. Another key justification for extending the retirement age is that a shorter mandatory retirement period can be a barrier to recruiting high-ranking judges with seniority from training institutes.
Meanwhile, the trend of corporate legal executives—core clients of law firms—becoming younger, with most now in their mid-50s or younger, is an important variable. If very senior lawyers with much higher class years take the lead, corporate clients may find it uncomfortable to assign work or communicate, which could hinder business. Another law firm attorney stated, "In practice, there are concerns that clients will prefer younger law firms with counterparts who are easier to communicate with." Soaring office rental costs are also a key factor pressuring generational change. While junior lawyers are forced to share offices in pairs due to a lack of space, allocating private secretaries and fixed costs to senior partners who are past their prime and have declining performance is increasingly seen as inefficient.
Calls for Differentiated Retirement Ages and Succession Plans Based on Work Characteristics
As a result, there are growing calls to move away from a uniform retirement age and instead differentiate it based on work intensity and job characteristics. For example, a retirement age of 60 is considered appropriate for M&A, which is physically demanding and involves dealing primarily with younger corporate executives, while 65 is deemed more efficient for litigation, where building long-term networks with the courts is essential. For hybrid departments that combine advisory and litigation work, such as antitrust, tax, and financial regulation, a retirement age of 63 has been suggested.
Law firm attorneys point out that it is urgent to introduce a systematic 'succession plan' that aligns with global standards. The idea is that once a partner reaches a certain age, the proportion of cases handled jointly with junior lawyers should be set at more than half, in order to promote a natural handover of clients.
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
The 'fade-out' retirement package, commonly used by foreign law firms, is attracting attention as an alternative. This approach grants partners approaching retirement about two years for the handover process, during which their annual compensation is gradually reduced. Even after retirement, they receive a portion (5–10%) of the revenue from clients they have brought in. This structure aligns the interests of senior partners, who are difficult to replace due to their experience, and law firms, which seek to prevent client attrition. Experts argue that such measures are necessary to minimize generational conflict within law firms and promote their long-term growth.
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.