A ruling that recognized the validity of success fee agreements in criminal cases between lawyers and clients has been appealed and is currently pending before the Supreme Court. It has been confirmed that the Korean Bar Association has requested a public hearing on the matter. As there is speculation that the Supreme Court may find it difficult to reach a conclusion without broader public discussion, attention is focusing on whether a public hearing will be held.


The Korean Bar Association (President Kim Jungwook) submitted a "Request for Public Hearing Procedures on Cases Related to Success Fees in Criminal Cases" to the Supreme Court on May 21.


Article 430, Paragraph 2 of the Civil Procedure Act stipulates, "The court of appeals may, where necessary to clarify the litigation relationship, hold hearings on specific matters to listen to statements from reference witnesses." According to Article 2 of the Supreme Court Rules on Hearings, the Supreme Court may, if necessary to clarify the litigation relationship and to proceed with hearings efficiently and intensively, order the parties to prepare for the hearing within a specified period of time.


In July 2015, the Supreme Court Grand Bench ruled, "Success fee agreements between lawyers and clients in criminal cases are invalid" (2015Da200111). However, nearly ten years later, on January 23, 2026, a lower court delivered a different judgment.


The Seoul Central District Court, in a case (2025Na7739) filed by the law firm Wi (Managing Partner Ho Jehun) against client A and others, overturned the first-instance ruling that had dismissed the plaintiff's claim, and instead ruled in favor of the plaintiff, stating, "A must pay the agreed amount of 33 million won and delayed damages to law firm Wi."


The court stated, "Not all success fee agreements in criminal cases should be uniformly considered contrary to social order. Only when, in an individual case, the specific agreement significantly undermines the integrity and fairness of the criminal justice system or is contrary to judicial justice, should it be deemed invalid."


Following this ruling, not only the Korean Bar Association and the Seoul Bar Association, but also major law firms and lawyers in Seocho-dong responded that this could lead to a change in prevailing judicial precedent.


This case has been assigned to the Supreme Court's Second Petty Bench, with Justice Kwon Youngjun (Judicial Research and Training Institute, 25th class) as the presiding justice. The Second Petty Bench consists of Justices Kwon Youngjun, Oh Kyungmi (25th class), Um Sangpil (23rd class), and Park Youngjae (22nd class).



Park Suyeon, The Law Times Reporter


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing