[Reporter’s Notebook] There Is a Reason for Resistance...The Election Commission Needs Major Reform View original image

The so-called "ballot paper shortage" that occurred during the 9th nationwide local elections is an incident that evokes dark memories in Korean society. The National Election Commission was established against the historical backdrop of the fraudulent March 15 election and the resistance of the April 19 Revolution.


To ensure that it faithfully fulfills its fundamental role of managing elections, it was granted the status and authority of a constitutionally independent body. However, as the reality unfolded in which citizens wishing to vote were forced to turn away due to the Commission's mistakes, the controversy spread rapidly. Throughout last weekend, citizens—mainly those in their 20s and 30s—gathered at Seoul Olympic Park, demanding a thorough investigation of the incident and a re-election. President Lee Jaemyung has also recognized the seriousness of the situation, instructing the establishment of a joint investigation headquarters between the police and prosecutors.


It is undeniable that the core of this crisis lies in the election authorities' poor management. Nevertheless, it is true that hardline conservative groups are raising their voices, advocating the so-called "rigged election conspiracy theory." Even if some political motives are suspected, it is not acceptable to turn a blind eye to or downplay this incident.


To borrow the words of Mao Zedong: "All resistance has its reasons" (造反有理). The young people at the center of these protests are a generation born into a democratized society, who have learned about the historical significance of suffrage—including the April 19 Revolution, the May 18 Gwangju Democratization Movement, and the June Democratic Uprising—through their education, and have internalized the importance of democracy through the impeachments of former presidents Park Geun-hye and Yoon Suk-yeol.


At the same time, this generation has acutely felt that the starting line and the process in areas such as employment, housing, and assets are not fair. To them, the ballot shortage incident is more than a simple administrative error; it may be perceived as a direct challenge to democracy and fairness.


Elections are the starting point of democracy. If we ignore their anger, what wavers next may not be the polling stations, but democracy itself. Even in the United States, the epicenter of so-called election fraud theories, the lack of careful political engagement led to the prolongation of the crisis.


The ruling and opposition parties must reach an agreement on a parliamentary investigation and a special prosecutor for the Election Commission as soon as possible. The courts must also deliver fast and fair results. The Election Commission, for its part, should promptly complete its own investigation into the facts and present improvement measures regarding ballot paper supply, on-site reporting systems, emergency response protocols, and the accountability structure of district, city, and county election commissions.



Furthermore, a major overhaul of the Election Commission is needed. While the election management system has so far strengthened independence and neutrality, the problem lies in the entrenched structure where no one is held accountable and where there is no oversight from inside or outside. This incident should be an opportunity to strengthen not only the independence of the Commission, but also its accountability and internal and external checks through a sweeping reform.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing