Supplementary Investigation Authority, Full Case Transfer, and Oversight of Special Judicial Police Must Be Included
Kim Yongmin and Park Eunjung's Amendment Criticized as "Self-Destructive Legislation"
Amendment Should Focus on Protecting the P

Seokjin Choi, Specialist at Loanbiz

Seokjin Choi, Specialist at Loanbiz

View original image

"It has been eight months since we filed the complaint, but the police have not even questioned the accused yet."


This is a common statement from frontline lawyers representing criminal victims. It is an undeniable fact that, due to the adjustment of investigative powers between the prosecution and the police, a surge of cases has been shifted to the police, resulting in significantly lengthened processing times for ordinary criminal complaints that do not attract public attention. Although some special prosecutors’ excessive abuse of investigative authority prompted the removal of the prosecutor’s investigative command, a significant narrowing of the range of cases that prosecutors can investigate, and a shift of investigative focus to the police, the side effects have been considerable.


Amidst these circumstances, only 116 days remain until the abolition of the Prosecution Service for the first time in 78 years since the founding of the Republic of Korea. Starting October 2, when the Act on the Organization and Operation of the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency, the Public Prosecution Service Act, and the revised Government Organization Act go into effect, investigations previously handled by the prosecution will be taken over by the newly established Serious Crimes Investigation Agency, and indictment work previously carried out by the prosecution will be handled by the newly created Public Prosecution Service.


From the adjustment of investigative authority between the prosecution and the police, through the so-called “complete deprivation of prosecutorial investigative powers,” and now to the abolition of the Prosecution Service, only the revision of the Criminal Procedure Act remains as the final stage of prosecutorial reform promoted by the Democratic Party of Korea. The key issues are: ▲whether Public Prosecution Service prosecutors will have supplementary investigative authority, ▲the transfer of all police investigation cases, and ▲the investigative command of prosecutors over special judicial police officers.


The Prosecution Reform Promotion Team under the Prime Minister’s Office plans to finalize a concrete proposal soon after consultations with the ruling party. However, Representative Yongmin Kim of the Democratic Party of Korea, who has often taken a confrontational stance against the government regarding prosecutorial reform, along with Representative Eunjeong Park of the Rebuilding Korea Party and independent Representative Hyukjin Choi, held a press conference on the 5th, calling for the revision of the “Citizen-Led New Criminal Procedure Act” and announced a bill that was not coordinated with the government.


Representative Yongmin Kim of the Democratic Party of Korea and other attendees are holding a press conference at the National Assembly Communication Hall on the 5th, urging the revision of the "Citizen-Led New Criminal Procedure Act" for desirable prosecutorial reform. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

Representative Yongmin Kim of the Democratic Party of Korea and other attendees are holding a press conference at the National Assembly Communication Hall on the 5th, urging the revision of the "Citizen-Led New Criminal Procedure Act" for desirable prosecutorial reform. Photo by Yonhap News Agency

View original image

In the bill Representative Kim publicly released, which he described as a “model answer crafted by civil society,” the direct investigative authority of prosecutors, as well as their supplementary investigative authority, would be completely abolished. The bill also blocks the principle of transferring all cases and excludes prosecutors’ investigative command over special judicial police officers. Representative Choi also argued that the authority for supplementary investigations should be transferred to the Anti-Corruption and Civil Rights Commission.


The issue of whether to grant supplementary investigative authority to Public Prosecution Service prosecutors is the most sensitive topic. Representative Kim and others argue that prosecutors should not be left with even the slightest investigative discretion. However, even President Jaemyung Lee, at a press conference marking his 100th day in office last September, cited specific cases to explain the necessity of such authority. Claiming that supplementary investigative requests are sufficient ignores the reality of the serious “ping-pong” of cases between the prosecution and the police, which has already become a major problem.


It is also difficult to deny the need to require all cases to be transferred, so that, even after the complete abolition of direct prosecutorial investigation authority and the consolidation of the initiation and closure of investigations under the police, potential investigative issues can be reviewed through records. In the case of investigative command over special judicial police officers, these officers from major government ministries have recently recommended to the Prosecution Reform Promotion Team that the command authority be retained, citing a lack of legal expertise and concerns about criminal liability.


Yongmin Kim and Eunjeong Park are, of course, members of the public. However, there are strong doubts as to whether they truly represent ordinary citizens, and whether the bills they have proposed are truly in the public interest. Attorney Hongseok Yang, an advisor to the Prosecution Reform Promotion Team and former head of the Public Interest Law Center at People’s Solidarity for Participatory Democracy, described the publicly released bill as “a revision of the Criminal Procedure Act that opposes, disregards, and endangers citizens,” even saying, “If this is ‘citizen-led,’ it is a self-destructive piece of legislation.”



The direction of the revision of the Criminal Procedure Act should not be set to fulfill the goals of a few hardline reformists who have openly expressed hostility toward the prosecution, but rather to protect all citizens from crime and to ensure the human rights of those under investigation. This is not an issue that can be amended later if it does not work out after trying it once.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing