19% of Executives at Eight Major Credit Card Companies Are in IT Roles
Only 3% Are Information Security Experts, Such as for Hacking Defense
"Authority to Lead Security Strategy for Risk Control Must Be Guaranteed"

Despite a series of information technology (IT) incidents causing difficulties for credit card companies, there is criticism that the number of executives responsible for information security remains insufficient and their ranks are relatively low. Experts advise that Korean companies should take cues from countries such as the United States and the United Kingdom, where security experts are appointed as executives and robust organizations and reporting lines are established under the Chief Information Security Officer (CISO).


Only One Executive Director-Level Security Officer at Card Companies: "Need to Increase Both Budget and Personnel" View original image

Only 8 Out of 46 IT Executives Are Responsible for Security

According to an analysis of quarterly reports disclosed by eight domestic credit card companies (Samsung, Shinhan, Hyundai, KB Kookmin, Lotte, Woori, Hana, and BC Card) as of the end of Q1, there were 46 IT-related executives among a total of 245 executives, accounting for 19%. In contrast, each of the eight companies had just one executive in charge of information security, making up only 3% of all executives. By rank, seven were at the executive director level, while one was serving as acting division head.


IT-related departments within card companies are largely divided into information security, IT operations, and consumer protection. Of the 46 IT-related executives, 38 (83%) were general IT executives focusing on tasks such as AX (AI Transformation), DX (Digital Transformation), platform development, and digital innovation, all aimed at improving profitability. Only eight executives (17%) were dedicated to information security, responsible for risk management such as defending against hacking.


It was also difficult to find information security experts among CEOs and outside directors. Most CEOs of card companies majored in fields such as management, economics, finance, public administration, or political science and diplomacy. Similarly, most outside directors specialized in management, economics, law, tax accounting, or public administration. While there were cases of appointing outside directors with engineering backgrounds, such as Shinhan Card outside director Choi Jaebung (mechanical engineering), Lotte Card outside director Moon Yongma (industrial engineering), and BC Card outside director Yoo Hyuk (computer engineering), it was rare for companies to appoint outside directors with practical experience in financial sector cybersecurity or information protection.


Academia Points to "Window Dressing" Management That Only Meets Minimum Standards

Academics argue that not only is the number of information security executives at card companies insufficient, but their authority within the organization is also weak. With general IT executives taking the lead in profitability-driven business, it is difficult for a single executive director-level information security executive to boldly request increased security budgets at board or management meetings.


Article 32 of the Enforcement Decree of the Personal Information Protection Act requires companies with annual sales of KRW 150 billion or more that process the personal information of over one million people or the sensitive/unique identification information of over 50,000 people to appoint a professional Chief Privacy Officer (CPO). However, there is no provision mandating that the position be at the senior executive director or vice president level. As a result, there is criticism that financial companies are engaging in "window dressing" management by appointing the lowest-ranking executive as the information security officer merely to meet the minimum legal requirements.


Sangmi Chae, professor at the School of Business Administration at Ewha Womans University, stated, "While securing personnel and bearing the associated costs is a reality, the more sophisticated the management system becomes, the more essential it is to have an information security executive who can put the brakes on profitability-focused business at board and management meetings. The most timely and fundamental countermeasure is to secure an information security executive who can ensure budget execution efficiency and command a company-wide security strategy."


She added, "If there is only one security officer per company, and that person is merely at the executive director level or serving as acting division head, there are bound to be serious limitations in the decision-making process. When marketing or sales departments led by senior executive directors or above call for streamlined security procedures in the name of improving profitability, it is virtually impossible, given the organizational culture of financial companies, for an executive director or acting division head to strongly oppose this."


Only One Executive Director-Level Security Officer at Card Companies: "Need to Increase Both Budget and Personnel" View original image

Industry: "Governance Structure of Holding or Owner Companies Must Be Considered... Reporting Lines Are More Important"

On the other hand, the credit card industry contends that the management reality, in which parent companies and groups are financial holding companies or large conglomerates, must be taken into account. In particular, for financial companies that are part of holding company groups or conglomerates, the number of executives is limited, and each company maintains information security executives in accordance with its size and organizational structure. The industry also argues that simply raising the rank of the information security executive does not directly translate into improved security standards.


An industry official stated, "Card companies are not just expanding information security budgets or reorganizing their structures—they are also making technological and strategic investments. Even if the information security officer is at the executive director level, they are able to present sufficiently independent opinions aligned with the CEO's management direction."


There is also an opinion that the essence lies in establishing the actual status of the information security officer within the organization and creating strong reporting lines. Rather than merely increasing the number of executives, it is more efficient to grant clear responsibility and authority to specialized executives.



Jiyong Seo, professor at the School of Business Administration at Sangmyung University, explained, "In the United States, United Kingdom, and Japan, it is common for companies to appoint a single CISO and establish a strong organization and direct reporting line to the board under that officer. What matters more than the rank of the information security officer is how much real authority and independence the officer has within the organization and how the reporting line is structured."


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing