Wife Proceeds with Procedure by Forging Husband's Consent Form

Hospital Claims "No Obligation for Direct Verification Under Regulations"

Pregnancy Revealed During Divorce Negotiations Exposes Incident

A controversy has arisen in Japan after it was revealed that a wife, who was separated from her husband, forged her husband's consent form and deceived the clinic by presenting a third party's sperm as her husband's sperm to receive infertility treatment, subsequently giving birth to a child. The husband has filed a compensation lawsuit, claiming that the hospital failed to properly verify his consent, thereby violating his right to self-determination.

A controversy has arisen in Japan after it was revealed that a wife, who was separated from her husband, forged her husband's consent form and deceived the clinic by presenting a third party's sperm as her husband's sperm to receive infertility treatment, subsequently giving birth to a child. The photo is unrelated to the specific content of the article. Pixabay

A controversy has arisen in Japan after it was revealed that a wife, who was separated from her husband, forged her husband's consent form and deceived the clinic by presenting a third party's sperm as her husband's sperm to receive infertility treatment, subsequently giving birth to a child. The photo is unrelated to the specific content of the article. Pixabay

View original image

On June 3, the Yomiuri Shimbun reported that a man living in Kyoto City recently filed a lawsuit at the Kyoto District Court, seeking approximately 11 million yen (around 10 million won) in damages, including compensation for emotional distress, against the medical corporation operating the hospital that handled infertility treatment for him and his wife. According to the report, the couple had entered into a contract with the hospital in 2020 for infertility treatment to have a second child, and had been preserving fertilized eggs via freezing. However, after January 2022, the couple began living separately and were in the process of negotiating a divorce.


During this time, the wife submitted a forged consent form with her husband's signature to the hospital and had a frozen embryo implanted in her uterus, but it is reported that the pregnancy attempt failed. Afterward, she again forged a consent form in her husband's name and provided sperm from a third party, presenting it as her husband's sperm. The hospital proceeded with the treatment using this sperm, and the wife gave birth to their second child in August 2023.


The incident came to light during the divorce negotiations when the wife disclosed her pregnancy. The husband filed a criminal complaint against his wife, and in April last year, the court found her guilty of forging and using private documents, sentencing her to 18 months in prison with a three-year suspended sentence. This verdict has been finalized.


The husband's side argues that if the hospital had directly and personally verified the additional sperm provision with the husband, it could have sufficiently detected the forged consent forms and the use of third-party sperm. He also claims that his right to self-determination regarding whether to have a child was infringed upon and holds the hospital responsible. The husband’s side also revealed that, in the ongoing divorce proceedings, the wife submitted a document stating that the child is not biologically related to the husband, and plans to submit this document as evidence in the current compensation lawsuit.



On the other hand, the hospital denies responsibility. In its written response, the hospital argued that at the time, there was no obligation under the regulations to verify spousal consent in person or by phone, and that there were no circumstances that would give rise to suspicion that the sperm was not the husband's or that the husband had not consented to the procedure. The hospital further commented to the media that "the lawsuit is based on a misunderstanding of the facts," and stated its intention to clarify during the trial that the hospital’s response was appropriate. The central issue in this lawsuit is expected to be to what extent hospitals must conduct spousal consent verification procedures during infertility treatment.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing