STEPI Proposes Institutionalizing a “R&D Forum for Public Deliberation”
Researcher Needs and Discussions Should Be Reflected in Project Planning

U.S., Europe, and Japan Link Researcher Roadmaps to Budgets
Call for Establishing a Deliberation-Based Innovation System

With the abolition of the preliminary feasibility study for national research and development (R&D) projects, establishing a system to incorporate the needs and opinions of the research field from the project planning stage has emerged as a new challenge. The Science and Technology Policy Institute (STEPI) has proposed that a so-called “R&D Forum for Public Deliberation,” where researchers can discuss the necessity and priorities of national R&D projects, should be institutionalized.


In the recently published Issue No. 65 of its “Science and Technology Policy Brief,” STEPI stated that the abolition of the preliminary feasibility study should be taken as an opportunity to shift toward a demand-driven project planning system centered on the research field.

Reference photo to help understand the article. The Asia Business Daily DB

Reference photo to help understand the article. The Asia Business Daily DB

View original image

According to the amendments made in February this year to the "Framework Act on Science and Technology" and the "National Finance Act," the preliminary feasibility study for national R&D projects has been abolished, while a new pre-assessment system for large-scale R&D projects has been introduced. As part of this process, a new “demand identification” procedure has been established to reflect the needs of the research field at the project planning stage.


The report emphasized that since national research facilities and research infrastructure projects require large-scale budgets over periods ranging from several years to several decades, thorough deliberation and verification by the actual end users—researchers—must precede any decision-making. The report stated that now is the right time to institutionalize the integration of research field needs and discussions into the national project planning system.


Major countries overseas are already operating deliberative systems centered on researcher communities. In the United States, research priorities are determined and linked to budget allocation through processes such as Snowmass, P5, and the Decadal Survey. In Europe, the European Strategy Forum on Research Infrastructures (ESFRI), UK Research and Innovation (UKRI), and the Helmholtz Association roadmap are utilized, while Japan operates its own Master Plan and the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology (MEXT) roadmap system.


Accordingly, STEPI proposed introducing a “R&D Forum for Public Deliberation” to separate the process in which researchers discuss scientific needs and research priorities from the government’s policy and budgetary decision-making. The institute also suggested that it is necessary to establish a communication channel connecting the government and the research field, so that the outcomes of public deliberation can be reflected in actual project planning.


The research team stated, “With the abolition of the preliminary feasibility study, the demand-driven project planning system for national R&D projects should be further advanced. In the long term, this should be developed into a deliberation-based innovation system, where researchers discuss the future of the nation and academic disciplines.”



This report was co-authored by Minjung Lee, Associate Research Fellow at STEPI, Jeongin Kwon, Researcher, and Bohun Hyun, Head of the R&D Fiscal Project Evaluation Center.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing