[Namsan Stroll] The Impact of Appearance on Female Leaders
Gray Hair in Male Candidates Seen as "Experience and Authority"
Excessive Retouching for Female Candidates to Appear Younger
Societal Pressure, Not Personal Ambition, May Be to Blame
The June local elections have concluded. Have you ever taken a close look at the campaign posters from this election? I noticed a distinct difference in image branding between male and female candidates. Among the male candidates, gray hair and determined expressions often stood out—aging was interpreted as a mark of authority. Female candidates, on the other hand, all displayed bright smiles and flawless, youthful appearances, regardless of their actual age. Why is there such a difference in posters aimed at the same voters for the same election?
Recently, a female city councilor in her 50s from the Netherlands was expelled after using campaign materials that were excessively retouched with artificial intelligence (AI). The decisive reason was voter distrust regarding the alteration of her appearance. Let’s flip the question for a moment: what if a male politician had used the same kind of retouched photo? The issue likely would not have arisen at all, and he probably would not have even felt the need for such retouching. Could it be that the female councilor felt compelled to cross the line with “Photoshopping” because of the implicit expectations of voters?
The history of this imbalance is long-standing. Henry VIII of England, in court painter Hans Holbein’s portrait, stands with his feet wide apart, shoulders squared, and gazes directly ahead—a pose exuding the aura of an imposing monarch. In reality, he was severely obese and so ill that he had to be carried by chair. Napoleon, who actually crossed the Alps on a scruffy mule, is depicted in paintings heroically commanding atop a white horse on a snowy mountain ridge. No one called this “excessive retouching”—they called it “image branding.” Yet Henry VIII himself applied a very different standard when it came to his fourth wife. He annulled his marriage to Anne of Cleves after just six months, claiming her appearance did not match her portrait. Thomas Cromwell, who arranged the marriage, was executed that same year. In the Han Dynasty, Wang Zhaojun was exiled to the Xiongnu because she refused to bribe the court painter, who then depicted her as unattractive. While eras and circumstances differed, women were always subject to evaluation under the gaze of others. Male powerholders acted as directors, commissioning their own images, while women were judged by those very images.
What does research say about the correlation between women and appearance? First, appearance functions in completely different ways for men and women in elections. A research team led by Todorov found that they could predict the winner of an election with 70% accuracy using only photographs of the candidates’ faces, and the result was the same even when the decision time was reduced to 0.1 seconds. According to a research team at Dartmouth led by Heman, the more competent a male candidate appeared, the higher his chances of winning. In contrast, competence alone was not enough for female candidates—they had to demonstrate both competence and warmth, and the more masculine their impression, the greater their chances of losing. This is a double burden: women must satisfy both expectations of ability and a sense of warmth and safety.
Second, merely mentioning a female candidate’s appearance—whether as praise or criticism—negatively impacts perceptions of her competence, regardless of the content. Research shows that for women, being attractive or not both pose problems. The premium and penalty for appearance operate simultaneously, creating a no-win situation. Third, these standards are equally applied in the corporate world. In a study analyzing 750 chief executive officers (CEOs), female CEOs were twice as likely as their male counterparts to be criticized for being “too ambitious or not ambitious enough,” and three times more likely to be deemed “lacking in confidence.” Not only appearance, but all aspects of behavior and decision-making are held to a different and harsher standard for women than for men.
Returning to the campaign posters, it was not the painter’s brushstrokes but the king’s unwillingness to see the whole picture that determined the fates of Wang Zhaojun and Anne of Cleves. Isn’t it much the same today, with female candidates universally erasing their wrinkles and forced to smile? The pressure came not from personal vanity, but from a society that makes women feel they must appear this way. Have we truly looked at male and female candidates with the same perspective and standards?
Hot Picks Today
"Two Spend 500,000 Won in a Flash, Yet Wait Two Hours?" ... 'Dreamland' Shunned by Kids and Foreign Tourists
- The Era of Getting 200 Million Won After 30 Years Is Over... A Japanese Bank's "Perpetual Department Head" Who Just Clocked In Cries Out
- Spain Hit by Its Worst Tragedy... Lee Kangin, Moreno and Real Madrid Join Soccer World in Mourning
- They Said, “Make It Your Home for Life” - Then Suddenly Kicked 200 Passengers Off... What Happened to the Around-the-World Cruise?
- "130 Rice Bowls Sold Out in a Day"... 'Unfiltered Face' Adds 8 Million Won to Night Market Sales: China's Bungeunwoo
Kim Seonghoe, CEO of Leadership Institute and Coach at Coaching Management Institute
© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.