Banks on Alert Over Final Reduction in Hong Kong ELS Fines
Successive Fines Multiply RWA Burden by Six Times
Prolonged High Exchange Rates Increase Foreign Asset Valuations, Pressuring Capital Ratios

As the conclusion regarding the incomplete sales of Hong Kong H Index (Hang Seng China Enterprises Index·HSCEI) equity-linked securities (ELS) has been postponed until after the local elections, banks are now focusing on the extent to which fines may be reduced. This is because the imposition of fines leads to an increase in risk-weighted assets (RWA), which in turn can lower the Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) capital ratio. Furthermore, with the Fair Trade Commission's sanctions related to alleged collusion on loan-to-value (LTV) ratios and the prolonged period of high exchange rates, the burden on financial holding companies to maintain their CET1 capital ratios is expected to increase even further.


Fines for ELS and LTV, Plus Soaring Exchange Rates... Financial Holdings Face Emergency in Defending CET1 Ratio View original image

Fines Multiply Operational Risk by Six Times

According to the financial industry on June 4, a conclusion regarding fines for Hong Kong ELS is expected at the Financial Services Commission's regular meeting scheduled for June 17. The Financial Supervisory Service is currently finalizing its review of the fine proposal.


The primary variable that banks are watching is the severity of the sanctions. Initially, the Financial Supervisory Service calculated fines totaling more than 4 trillion won for five banks—KB Kookmin, Shinhan, Hana, NH Nonghyup, and Standard Chartered Bank Korea—but adjusted the amount to approximately 1.4 trillion won in February, reflecting their efforts toward voluntary compensation. However, since a re-examination is underway at the request of the Financial Services Commission, there is a possibility that the final fine amount may be reduced further.


When fines are imposed, they are reflected in net profit, but banks must also recognize an additional operational risk amounting to six times the fine, thereby increasing RWA. For example, if a fine of 100 billion won is imposed, RWA would increase by approximately 600 billion won. As a result, this exerts downward pressure on the CET1 capital ratio.


An official from a commercial bank commented, "Fines are not a frequent occurrence, and the fact that they are reflected at six times their value when calculating RWA can temporarily put significant pressure on capital ratio management. The nature of this risk is different from the credit and market risks that we routinely manage."


LTV Sanctions and the Authorities' 13% Guideline Pressure

Banks are also closely monitoring the outcome of lawsuits related to the Fair Trade Commission's allegations of collusion on LTV ratios. If fines for LTV collusion are added to the mix, the burden on banks to manage their CET1 capital ratios will increase further. Previously, the Fair Trade Commission imposed a total fine of 272,014,000,000 won on KB Kookmin, Shinhan, Hana, and Woori Bank. In response, these banks filed lawsuits in March seeking to overturn the Fair Trade Commission's fine decision.


With financial authorities recently recommending that banks maintain a CET1 capital ratio of at least 13%, there is analysis that if both ELS and LTV-related fines are imposed simultaneously, it could affect shareholder return plans such as dividend policies or share buybacks.


Exchange rate risk is also a key variable that financial holding companies are monitoring. On this day, the won-dollar exchange rate on the Seoul foreign exchange market opened at 1,530.0 won, up 13.6 won from the previous closing price. Banks hold a variety of foreign currency assets, not only in U.S. dollars, but also in euros, yen, and others. If the value of the won continues to decline, the won-denominated value of banks' foreign currency assets increases, which leads to a rise in RWA. Since the CET1 capital ratio is calculated by dividing common equity capital by RWA, a higher RWA results in a lower capital ratio.



However, as exchange rate risk is something banks routinely manage, the current exchange rate levels have already been factored into business plans. The financial sector explains that, as high exchange rates are increasingly considered the 'new normal' of the economic environment rather than a temporary shock, banks are strengthening their monitoring of the potential for a prolonged period of high exchange rates rather than short-term volatility. Accordingly, defending the CET1 capital ratio is likely to be the core management task for banks in the second half of the year.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing