A court has ruled that it is illegal to notify an employee of termination by simply stating "for management reasons" without specifying the concrete grounds for dismissal. The Seoul Administrative Court’s 13th Division (Presiding Judge Jin Hyunseop) ruled against the plaintiff in a lawsuit (case number 2025gu-hap54516) filed by Hospital Director A against the Chairperson of the Central Labor Relations Commission, seeking to overturn a decision on a remedy for unfair dismissal.


[Facts]

A, who operated a clinic in Eumseong-gun, North Chungcheong Province, hired Doctor B through a job posting. In July 2024, A delivered a notice of contract termination to B, stating that the employment relationship would end for management reasons.

The court ruled that notifying an employee of dismissal without specifying concrete reasons for the termination is unlawful. An unrelated photo. Pixabay.

The court ruled that notifying an employee of dismissal without specifying concrete reasons for the termination is unlawful. An unrelated photo. Pixabay.

View original image

[Court’s Judgment]

The evidence submitted by A alone is insufficient to recognize that the employment relationship between A and B was terminated by mutual agreement or by B’s voluntary resignation. Rather, it is reasonable to conclude that A unilaterally notified B of the termination of the employment contract against B’s wishes.


According to Article 27 of the Labor Standards Act, an employer must notify a worker in writing of the reason and timing for dismissal in order for the termination to be effective. However, although A actually dismissed B for “falsifying career information, poor work performance, and lack of diligence in work attitude,” the notice given did not specify any of these reasons and was simply issued as “for management reasons.” This constitutes a violation of the written notice requirement and is therefore invalid.


Even when considering A’s claim that the dismissal was for management reasons, there is insufficient basis to acknowledge that there was an urgent managerial necessity to dismiss B. There is also no evidence that A made efforts to avoid dismissal or selected the employee based on reasonable and fair criteria.



Kim Jisoo, Legal News Reporter


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing