The Corruption Investigation Office for High-ranking Officials (CIO) discovered evidence that the child of former Prosecutor General Woojung Shim (26th class of the Judicial Research and Training Institute) had forged documents while joining the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and its affiliated institutions, but delegated the investigation to the police. This is because the CIO cannot initiate investigations into individuals who are not high-ranking public officials, and it also lacks the authority to formally transfer such cases, making it impossible to open a case in the first place. While the CIO argues that its investigative scope should be broadened, critics point out that this would conflict with the current CIO Act system.


On May 27, the CIO cleared former Prosecutor General Shim of all charges. Allegations had been raised that Shim gave special favors to hire his daughter at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the Korea National Diplomatic Academy as a researcher. Shim, along with former Foreign Minister Tae-yeol Cho and former President of the Korea National Diplomatic Academy Cheolhee Park, had been accused of abuse of authority. After a civil group filed a complaint in March 2025, the CIO expanded its investigation over the course of a year and identified allegations involving eight additional individuals.

Shim Woo-jung, Prosecutor General. The Asia Business Daily.

Shim Woo-jung, Prosecutor General. The Asia Business Daily.

View original image

Among the matters detected, the CIO requested that the police investigate Ms. Shim's alleged forgery of private documents and the alleged falsification of official documents by public servants involved in the hiring process. Under the CIO Act, the CIO's investigative jurisdiction is generally limited to high-ranking officials equivalent to grade 3 or higher (Article 2, Paragraph 4, Subparagraph (l)).


The CIO argues that its investigative scope should be expanded to the level of a special prosecutor or the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency. Yoonje Lee (29th class), a professor at Myongji University School of Law who served on the Justice Ministry and Prosecutorial Reform Committee in 2017, said, "Although the reform committee announced the CIO bill at that time, the scope of the CIO's investigative authority was unfairly restricted through government discussions." He added, "Neither the Special Prosecutor Act nor the Serious Crimes Investigation Agency Act has ever limited the subjects of investigative authority, nor has such a restriction ever been required by court precedent."


The CIO also believes that there is a need to address the unreasonable situation in which suspects have to be investigated by multiple agencies. Recently, the court ruled that the prosecution has no grounds to conduct supplementary investigations for CIO cases, so cases lacking CIO investigative authority are expected to go through several stages—from the CIO to the police, and then to the prosecution. The CIO has requested that the Ministry of Justice submit a proposed amendment to the CIO Act as of April.


There are opposing views as well. Jaepyung Park (39th class), a professor at Chungbuk National University Law School, stated, "The CIO was established as a specialized investigative agency to punish occupational crimes among high-ranking officials. If the scope of investigative authority is broadened, it would become a general investigative agency like the police, which goes against its founding purpose."


Another law school professor in Seoul added, "If there are no allegations related to occupational duties—the main focus—then even if other allegations are detected, there is a provision that requires all such cases to be transferred to the prosecution. The legislative intent to limit investigative authority to high-ranking officials is clear." When the CIO issues a non-prosecution disposition for a high-ranking official, it must transfer any remaining allegations to the Supreme Prosecutors' Office (Article 27).


The CIO Act does not specify how to handle allegations for which investigative authority is lacking. While there is a provision allowing the CIO to transfer a case to another investigative agency based on the nature or magnitude of the case (Article 24, Paragraph 3), such a transfer requires the case to be opened—that is, an investigation must be formally initiated first. For allegations involving non-high-ranking officials, the only option is to request an investigation by another agency.


There are concerns about what happens if the CIO does not request an investigation or if the agency receiving the request fails to investigate. Investigative agencies have a duty to investigate if there is suspicion of a crime (Criminal Procedure Act, Article 197, Paragraph 1), but this principle may not always be upheld. Requests for investigation are governed not by law but by administrative rules, which stipulate that the CIO chief can make such a request if asked to do so by a prosecutor (Investigation Request Guideline, Article 3).


Professor Park said, "There needs to be a legal provision specifying that the CIO must request an investigation for detected allegations and that the agency receiving the request must investigate unless there are justifiable reasons not to do so."



Seongdong Park, Legal News Reporter


※This article is based on content supplied by Law Times.

This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing