Ideological Showdown and Battle for Political Identity

[Reporter’s Notebook] Superintendent Elections Where Education Is Lost View original image

"There is no education, only politics."


This is the common lament among parents ahead of the nationwide elections for superintendents of education on June 3. One acquaintance told this reporter, "Who should I vote for to reduce private education costs?" and added, "No matter who I pick, I don't see a single candidate who can truly solve educational problems, and that is frustrating." This is because the superintendent elections have devolved into ideological battles and a contest of political clarity, pushing actual policy discussions to the background.


Political parties are not listed on superintendent election ballots. These are nonpartisan elections, intended to preserve the political neutrality of education by excluding party endorsements. However, when you look at the actual campaign scene, there is little difference from other elections. Every campaign season, "blue jackets" and "red jackets" appear, and candidates eagerly signal which political camp they are closest to. Although the direct election system for superintendents was introduced in 2007 to separate education from politics, every time an election is held, politics ends up overshadowing education—a paradox that keeps repeating itself.


This phenomenon is even more pronounced in this election. In the Seoul superintendent race, which has the highest competition rate nationwide, eight candidates are running. This is the result of both the conservative and progressive camps failing to unify their candidates. While it may appear that voters have more opportunities to compare and choose from a range of policies, the reality is different. As candidates within the same camp compete against each other, the focus shifts from policy scrutiny to displays of strength and rallying their support base—a pattern that keeps recurring.


In the actual Seoul superintendent race, candidates clashed fiercely in debates over political and ideological issues such as the cancellation of indictments or the issue of homosexuality, rather than focusing on education policy. During the process of trying to unify candidates, disputes, lawsuits, and legal complaints erupted, turning the campaign into a mudslinging contest. Both inside and outside the education office, there is cynicism that "the superintendent candidates, who are supposed to teach students conflict resolution and cooperation, are themselves displaying uneducational behavior." Some candidates have even changed their positions depending on ideological issues or promoted meetings with certain political or religious figures, only to scramble to contain the controversy afterward.


The real problem is that amid these exhausting debates, voters are losing the opportunity to compare candidates' educational policies. Critical educational issues abound, including the crisis in public education, soaring private education expenses, the restoration of teachers' authority, and nurturing talent for the age of artificial intelligence (AI). However, as campaigning intensifies, candidates spend more time attacking their rivals than discussing educational philosophies or policies. This is why criticisms such as "No matter who is elected, education won't improve," and "With so many candidates, policy is invisible," continue to emerge.



Twenty years ago, the direct election of superintendents had a clear purpose: to make education independent from politics. But now the current superintendent elections force us to question whether that purpose is truly being realized. If elections continue to prioritize politics over education, voter apathy and cynicism will only deepen. It is time to reform the system so that elections serve the purpose of education.


This content was produced with the assistance of AI translation services.

© The Asia Business Daily. All rights reserved. Unauthorized AI training and use prohibited.

Today’s Briefing